Digital Business Training Programs: Evidence from Jordan
How to cite
Alhorr, Layane. 2021. "Digital Business Training Programs: Evidence from Jordan." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0007790. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7790-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
In many parts of the world, women’s mobility and access to opportunities are still limited by demands on their time at home, conservative gender norms, and poor transportation. As smartphone and social media usage rates escalate in developing countries, it is increasingly important to understand whether these accessible technologies can be used to deliver remote, flexible, and more inclusive programs to women. Working with microfinance clients in Jordan, which has one of the lowest female labor force participation rates in the world, I study the take-up and impact of a virtual business training program designed to leverage social media apps and to be delivered on smartphones. To evaluate the training’s impact, I aim to randomize interested applicants to (1) a control arm, (2) a training only arm, or (3) a training and social media exposure arm. The social media exposure arm places participants in chat groups and exposes them to a “curated social media feed” of online business pages and tutorials. Given the low rates of economic participation by women, the intervention is meant to explore whether existing digital networking sites can be leveraged to enhance women’s access to collaboration and learning opportunities that they might otherwise lack in their immediate communities.
Intervention
The core training bundle includes the following:
1- On a password-protected website: users will have access to videos covering the story of a young Jordanian woman and her journey to open a business, in addition to accompanying short lectures, animations, and clips on real businesses by Jordanian women. The material covers 3 modules, and participants can get a certificate at the end of each module. The 3 modules cover the following themes:
- Motivation and ideation
- Financing, accounting, and HR
- Growth and marketing
2- On WhatsApp, users will be sent the following:
- a suggested schedule and reminders to watch the training
- prompts asking participants to complete reflection exercises related to the training
- “flashcards” containing summaries / rules of thumb from the 3 modules
The social media exposure arm implements the WhatsApp part of the training bundle through groups of 5-6 participants, as opposed to individual communication, and sends each group a curated social media feed of business profiles and tutorials.
Experimental design
As the microfinance I am working with has a limit on the number of trainees it can register per year, I am recruiting and randomizing interested women into one of the below treatment arms:
1- control arm: their access to the training is postponed by a year
2- treatment arm: will get access to the training bundle, which includes individual reminders on WhatsApp
3- treatment and social media exposure arm: will access the training bundle + get placed in WhatsApp groups of 5-6 participants. These groups are meant to increase participants' exposure to existing and aspiring business owners in two ways. First, directly through networking in these chatting groups; and second, indirectly through a "curated social media feed" of business profiles and tutorials on social media. In practice, this feed entails sending participants highlights of business ideas, business skill tutorials, and businesses pages as publicly available on Facebook, Instagram, and Youtube.
Randomization into the above treatments will be stratified by the following:
- business ownership: whether women currently own a business, have owned a now closed business in the past two years, or neither
- reported struggle to afford Internet: while all women have access to a smartphone and internet, some of them suffer more than others to pay their internet bills. Since the training is virtual, I plan to stratify by reported struggles to pay Internet
- willingness to participate in the social media exposure groups: participants have the option to participate in the training while opting out of the social media exposure group, in which case they would just be randomized into control vs. training.
In total, these constitute 12 strata.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.