The effect of affordable daycare on health and economic well-being over the life course in India: A cluster-randomized impact evaluation study

How to cite

Harper, Sam; Nandi, Arijit; Agarwal, Parul; Maloney, Shannon. 2015. "The effect of affordable daycare on health and economic well-being over the life course in India: A cluster-randomized impact evaluation study." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0000774. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.774-3.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Sam Harper* , Arijit Nandi , Parul Agarwal , Shannon Maloney

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0000774
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.774-3.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2014-10-01 – 2018-03-01
Countries
India (Rajasthan)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/774

Abstract

There are structural barriers to women's economic participation and empowerment in India. Among these barriers is the lack of affordable and reliable daycare services. The responsibility of providing childcare is imposed primarily on women and contributes to gender inequalities experienced by women over the life-course. The provision of affordable and reliable daycare services is a potentially important policy lever for reducing gender inequality and improving health and socioeconomic well-being over the life-course. Access to daycare might reduce barriers to labor force entry and generate economic opportunities for women, improve education for girls caring for younger siblings, and promote nutrition and learning among children. However, empirical evidence concerning the effects of daycare programs over the life-course in low-and-middle-income countries is scarce. We propose a cluster-randomized impact evaluation for estimating the effect of a community-based daycare program on health and economic well-being over the life-course among women and children living in rural Rajasthan, India. This interdisciplinary research initiative will address an important research gap and has the potential to inform policies for improving the daycare system in India in ways that promote inclusive economic growth.

Intervention

The proposed intervention is the introduction of full time, affordable daycare centers, or balwadis, that will be implemented by Seva Mandir, in 80 hamlets in the Udaipur district of Rajasthan. These hamlets will serve as the treatment group for the randomized control trial. Each of the balwadis will provide childcare, nutritious food and supplements, basic medicines, and preschool education to children 1-6 years old. Balwadis are operated by local women, called Sanchalikas, who meet with mothers on a quarterly basis to discuss their child's progress. They also promote immunization of children by maintaining immunization records and following-up with parents and government nurses.

In December 2014 and early January 2015, potential study hamlets were selected. These hamlets were selected from areas where Seva Mandir works and operates programs besides the balwadi program. We identified 160 eligible hamlets that satisfied five criteria, specifically: (1) no readily accessible balwadi or government-run aganwadi nearby (within 1.5 kilometers) to reduce the potential for contamination effects; (2) minimum number of children in the appropriate age range (>24) in the village to ensure adequate demand; (3) existing building suitable for a balwadi; (4) a qualified Sanchalika, living in the study hamlet or nearby, to operate the balwadi; and (5) adequate demand from the village council (Panchayat) for a new balwadi, as expressed by an application for a balwadi. Seva Mandir provided a listing of 160 hamlets that satisfied these criteria to the study investigators, after which a household census was conducted in each hamlet to confirm the eligibility of the hamlet, enumerate the population, and identify potential households for inclusion.

In January 2015, we conducted a household census in each of the 160 hamlets to confirm the eligibility of the hamlet, enumerate the population, and identify potential respondents for inclusion. Eligible respondents were mothers (biological or guardian) with a child between one and six years of age. The total number of eligible respondents was similar to our desired sample size. Therefore, we did not probabilistically sample individuals among eligible respondents and all eligible respondents were selected for interview.

Within each eligible household, a woman with a child less than 6 years old was randomly selected as the primary respondent using a Kish procedure. Outcomes will be measured via in-person survey at baseline, just before the balwadis are introduced, at midline, approximately halfway through the intervention period, and at endline, approximately 18-24 months post the start of the intervention.

Experimental design

The intervention, i.e. the introduction of balwadis, will be randomly assigned to 80 of the 160 hamlets. The remaining 80 hamlets will serve as comparison group. The survey, which measures the study outcomes, will be administered at the baseline (before the intervention starts), at the mid-line (one year after the intervention starts), and at the end-line (when the intervention/program ends).

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization was done in office by a computer (using Stata software's random number generator)
Randomization unit
We randomly assigned the 160 hamlets to treatment or control stratified by block (Badgaon, Girwa, Jhadol, Herwara, Kotra) because we wanted to prevent random variations in the distributions of blocks across treatment groups from confounding effects (e.g., if women in treated hamlets were more likely to reside in blocks with more economic opportunities). A random integer was assigned to each of the five blocks and each of the 160 hamlets using a random number generator.
Clusters
160 village hamlets
Observations
3200 individuals
Arms
80 treated hamlets; 80 control hamlets
Primary outcomes
We will measure the impact of our intervention on self-reported empowerment (self-esteem, role in decision-making, freedom of mobility, and control of material resources), measured via in-person survey. Other outcomes include labor market attachment (employment status, occupation, hours worked), economic status (personal and household income), time use, and mental health (depressive symptoms). Additionally, we will measure nutritional status (stunting, wasting, underweight) among children less than six years of age, as well as educational attainment and literacy among school-aged children.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords