Credit Card Statements: Effects of simplification, anchoring and salience on understanding and on repayment decisions.

How to cite

Soki, Erika; Falcão, Natalia Nogueira Lima; Almeida, Raquel Melo de; Cruz, Diogo Nogueira; Teixeira, Lucas Iten; Filho, Arnaldo Francisco Vitaliano; Taborda, Juan; Barlach, Breno; Gómez, José María Ortiz. 2021. "Credit Card Statements: Effects of simplification, anchoring and salience on understanding and on repayment decisions.." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0007722. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7722-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Erika Soki* , Natalia Nogueira Lima Falcão , Raquel Melo de Almeida , Diogo Nogueira Cruz , Lucas Iten Teixeira , Arnaldo Francisco Vitaliano Filho , Juan Taborda , Breno Barlach , José María Ortiz Gómez

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0007722
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7722-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2021-06-07 – 2021-11-30
Countries
Brazil ()
JEL codes
D14, O16, D91
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/7722

Abstract

This laboratory RCT will investigate how simplifying language and reorganizing information in Credit Card Statements affects the understanding of selected information about credit limits and costs associated to repayment and credit card usage. It will also research how anchoring and salience could play a key role in determining individual repayment decisions.

Intervention

The experiment will test if using credit card statements with simplified language and design helps individuals make better financial decisions. The idea is that information conveyed by credit card statements tends to be presented in a technical and confusing way, which limits individuals understanding. Therefore, by simplifying the statements, one expects people understand better the use and risk of utilizing this particular financial product.

To assess this hypothesis individuals will be randomly allocated to a control group or one of two treatment groups. The control group will be shown a statement that is similar to those currently available for a local credit card. Treatment group 1, will view an improved statement that changes the design and wording of the document trying to convey better financial information related to repayment options, costs and fees of credit cards. Treatment 2 incorporates the changes in the improved statement as T1, but highlights the lowest interest payment options (salience). All statements are based on the same information and the same hypothetical fees and charges.

Aside from the main intervention related to credit card statements, we want to test if anchoring can affect financial decision making when paying financial obligations. For this purpose we will randomly allocate half of the participants of the control and treatment groups to different payment screens. The control group for this intervention will see a blank form when deciding the amount of the payment they are willing to make, and the treated group will see a prefilled payment form that shows the total amount.

This second intervention is focused on anchoring and pre-filled payment screens. The idea is that pre-filling amounts to pay can nudge individuals to paying the statement in a way it reduces fees and interests associated with the use of the financial product.

Given this design, the experiment will consist of one pure treatment group and 5 treatment branches as follows:
Intervention 1 - Different credit card statements:
- Control (T0)
- Improved statement design and clearer language (T1)
- Improved statement T1 with focus on low interests (T2).

Intervention 2 - Prefilled payment form:
- Control: blank form (Pure Control - T0.0), Prefilled form (T0.1)
- T1: blank form (T1.0), Prefilled form (T1.1)
- T2: blank form (T2.0), Prefilled form (T2.1)

Experimental design

Participants will be randomly allocated into one of the following treatment arms: Pure control(T0.0), Control anchored at total value (T0.1), T1 anchored at zero (T1.0), T1 anchored at total (T1.1), T2 anchored at zero (T2.0) and T2 anchored at total (T2.1). Based on the statement presented, participants will be asked to decide on repayment of the credit card and then proceed to respond to a series of survey questions to test their understanding regarding credit card limits, consequences for each repayment option and card costs.

Design details

Randomization method
Respondents will be randomly assigned to view Control, Treatment 1 and Treatment 2 statements by the panel software. Within each group, participant will also be randomly assigned to one of the anchoring effects screens (Pure Control, T0.1, T1.0, T1.1, T2.0, T2.1).
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
No clusters
Observations
3,000 individuals
Arms
500 observations for each treatment arm will be collected, totaling 3,000 respondents.
Primary outcomes
1. Survey measures of understanding 2. Time to answer 3. Experimental measures of repayment decisions
Secondary outcomes
Survey measures of financial literacy

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords