Long-term Direct and Intra-Household Spillover Effects of a Conditional Cash Transfer Program: Experimental Evidence from Colombia
How to cite
Busso, Matias; Barrera-Osorio, Felipe; Bonilla, Leonardo; Angelucci, Manuela; Munoz-Morales, Juan Sebastian. 2021. "Long-term Direct and Intra-Household Spillover Effects of a Conditional Cash Transfer Program: Experimental Evidence from Colombia." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0007719. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7719-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This project studies the long-term effects of a conditional cash transfer program on a rich array of education and labor market outcomes of the beneficiaries and their family members.
Intervention
In 2005, the city of Bogotá, Colombia, in collaboration with researchers at Fedesarrollo (Colombia) and JPAL (US), implemented a conditional cash transfer (CCT) program aimed at reducing dropout rates in secondary education among low-income students (In Colombia, secondary education includes grades 6-11). In this proposal, we discuss the estimation strategy of the long-term effects of the program on a rich array of education and labor market outcomes of the beneficiaries and their family members. One important objective of the study is the estimation of spillover effects on non-beneficiary minors living in a household with a treated sibling. We rely on a randomized control trial that allocated the program at random to CHILDREN among a set of families with eligible students.
The intervention took place in 2005, and was implemented in two of the 12 localities of Bogotá, Colombia, under the Conditional Subsidies for School Attendance Program (``Subsidios Condicionados a la Asistencia Escolar'', in Spanish) designed by the city's Secretary of Education. The program evaluated alternative delivery methods of conditional cash transfers by assigning students randomly to three different treatment arms (Barrera-Osorio et al.,2011, 2019):
1) A ``BASIC'' conditional cash transfer in which participant families received 30,000 pesos every two months (around \$15 USD) if the student attended 80 percent of the classes in that month.
2) A ``SAVINGS TREATMENT'' that vary the timing of the transfer. Households in this treatment arm received two-thirds of the amount (20,000 COP or roughly \$10 USD) every two months, and the remaining third was kept in a bank account. The saved funds were available at the beginning of the next academic year. A total of 100,000 (\$50 USD) was given if the students fully met the requirements.
3) A ``TERTIARY TREATMENT'' that modified the conditionality requirement of the transfer. Students received two-thirds of the original bi-monthly sum (20,000 COP), but upon high school graduation they received a total amount of 600,000 COP ($300 USD), which was given immediately if the student enrolled in a tertiary education program or after a year if the student did not enrol.
The saving and basic treatment transfer provided roughly the same amount of money (e.g., they are income-neutral); the transfer in the tertiary experiment was larger than in the first two.
The program was highly advertised in both localities during January and February 2005, and registration took place in a 15-day window at the end of February and the beginning of March 2005. Participating families were not aware of the existence of multiple treatments. The program was advertised as one that provided incentives to participate in school.
Experimental design
The experiment took place in San Cristóbal and Suba, two localities (out of 12) in Bogotá with high prevalence of low-income households. Treatment assignment was implemented differently in each locality. In San Cristóbal, eligible participants from grade six to 11 were randomized into the control group, the basic treatment, and the savings treatment. In Suba students in grades nine to 11 were randomly assigned to either the control group or the tertiary treatment. Thus, it is not possible to compare the tertiary treatment with the basic or the savings treatment.
Eligibility into the program required that: 1) at least one parent was present at the moment of registration; 2) students had finished fifth grade for the basic and saving treatment, and eighth grade for the tertiary treatment; 3) students were enrolled but had not graduated; and 4) the family was classified in the two lowest categories of Colombia's poverty index created with SISBEN's information. A total of 17,309 students, from 12,674 households, registered: 10,947 in San Cristóbal and 6,362 in Suba. In terms of households, 8,812 registered only 1 individual; 3,190 registered 2 individuals; 580 registered 3 individuals; 83 households registered 4; and 9 household registered 5 individuals.
The random allocation of benefit provides two sources of exogenous variation in treatment assignment: variation across treated and control children which allows to identify the direct treatment effects of the CCT among treated students; and variation of treated and control children within the same household which allows us to identify intra-household spillovers. More specifically, the nature of the randomization allows us to consistently estimate three effects. First, the effect on children who were directly targeted by the program, by comparing outcomes of beneficiaries and non-beneficiaries of the transfer (“direct effects”). Second, the effect on non-treated siblings, by contrasting outcomes of untreated siblings in a household with beneficiaries versus untreated siblings in a household without beneficiaries (“sibling effects”). Third, the indirect effect on parents of eligible children, by comparing outcomes of parents with children who were randomized to receive the transfer with those of parents of eligible children all of whom were randomized to the control group (“parent effects”).
Two studies found positive treatment effects of this CCT program on students' academic outcomes. Barrera-Osorio, Bertrand, Linden, and Perez-Calle (2011) show that, after one year of the program, the savings and tertiary treatments increased enrollment remarkably in secondary and tertiary education. Barrera-Osorio, Linden, and Saavedra (2019) analyse longer-term effects on tertiary education after 8-12 years since the program implementation. They find that the savings treatment does better at inducing students to enroll in better tertiary education programs which was unexpected because the program did not condition on tertiary enrollment.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.