Social preferences and responses to changes in inequality perception

How to cite

Senn, Julien; Fehr, Ernst; Epper, Thomas; Henkel, Aljosha. 2021. "Social preferences and responses to changes in inequality perception." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0007716. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7716-1.2

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Julien Senn* , Ernst Fehr , Thomas Epper , Aljosha Henkel

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0007716
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7716-1.2
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2021-05-27 – 2021-07-31
Countries
Switzerland (German and French-Speaking Cantons)
JEL codes
D31, D72, H23, H24, D83
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/7716

Abstract

We examine the role of social preferences for individuals’ responses to changes in inequality perceptions. In previous research (Epper-Fehr-Senn 2020) we have shown that social preferences strongly reduce the decline of support for redistribution that occurs at higher incomes: Higher income levels are associated with a strong decline in political support for redistribution for selfish individuals but inequality averse individuals and individuals with social welfare concerns exhibit a much smaller decline. Here, we study how individuals respond to a downwards shock in their beliefs about inequality and how their response interacts with their social preferences. We hypothesize that an information shock that induces individuals to reduce their belief about the share of income received by the top 1% of income earners in Switzerland will lead to an average decrease in support for redistribution. We further conjecture that this reduction is particularly pronounced for inequality averse individuals with an above-median income (relative to selfish individuals with an above-median income). This conjecture follows from the results reported in Epper-Fehr-Senn (2020), indicating that inequality averse individuals with above-median incomes display larger political support for redistribution than selfish individuals with an above-median income.

Intervention

See below.

Experimental design

Our experimental design involves 2 waves.

In wave 1 (which we conducted in 2020), we measured individuals’ social preferences (using dictator games), their beliefs about income inequality in Switzerland, their (self-reported) income, their beliefs about the determinants of success, and a variety of other questionnaire measures. This data allows us to identify the selfish and the inequality averse individuals, and to classify individuals according to their self-reported incomes. In addition, the data on beliefs about income inequality indicate that a large majority of subjects greatly overestimates income inequality. We aim at shocking these perceptions about income inequality in wave 2.

In wave 2 (the upcoming study, which is conducted with the same sample as wave 1), we test the predictions described above by providing half of our sample with information that is aimed at reducing their perception of inequality. Because the majority of subjects overestimate the share of income that the top 1% of income earners receive, providing true information about the share that the top 1% actually receives will shock the inequality perception of most subjects downwards.

Altogether, the data from wave 1 together with the information shock treatments in wave 2 make it possible to assess the causal impact of information-induced shocks in perceived inequality on political support for redistributive policies, and to study the role of social preferences and income levels for individuals’ response to the information shock.

Design details

Randomization method
We implement a stratified randomization protocol (to treatment and control) with 24 strata. The strata are generated by distinguishing between below and above-median income earners, below and above median beliefs regarding whether effort/ or luck determines individual success, 3 social preferences groups (inequality averse, social welfare concerns, selfish; measured in the baseline), and above versus below median belief about income inequality in Switzerland.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
-
Observations
1383 individuals successfully participated in the first wave of this study conducted in 2020. Participants were contacted by a national survey provider (LINK) and are broadly representative of the Swiss population in the French-speaking and German-speaking parts of Switzerland. We will invite all these 1383 participants for the second wave. According to our panel provider, we can expect a participation rate of roughly 70 to 75%, which would result in 968 to 1037 individuals, i.e., roughly 1000 individuals.
Arms
roughly 500 in the information shock treatment and roughly 500 control condition
Primary outcomes
Donations to civic organizations that support an upcoming redistributive initiative (the so-called 99% initiative) or to civic organizations that oppose this redistributive initiative. The 99% initiative aims at increasing taxation for the top 1% income earners and using the tax proceeds to reduce taxes for low and middle labor incomes or increase social transfers to low income households.
Secondary outcomes
We will also explore the effects of the treatment (and its interaction with income and social preferences) on other questionnaire measures of support for redistribution such as “the government should reduce income inequality by increasing taxes for the rich".

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords