Orientare alla Scelta

How to cite

Manzella, Elisa; Argentin, Gianluca; Barbetta, Gianpaolo. 2021. "Orientare alla Scelta." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0007696. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7696-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Elisa Manzella* , Gianluca Argentin , Gianpaolo Barbetta

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0007696
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7696-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2021-09-19 – 2023-12-31
Countries
Italy (Milano)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/7696

Abstract

A conscious educational choice requires to be accompanied by an effective school guidance, a key factor for the success of students' educational paths and for the effectiveness and equity of the entire school system.
Teachers may significantly influence the school choices of students and their families, but previous research showed that their advice may be biased and could contribute to the reproduction of educational inequalities (more precsierly the ones' due to students' social originis, migratory background and gender).
I Italy a guidance advice is provide by teachers to all students at the end of lower secondary school.
In this experiment, we provide to teachers' the opportunity to attend a professional development course focused on school guidance and providing them both awareness about related social inequalities and tips regarding how to reduce their potential biases.
The intervention is delivered though a dedicated web platform, where each teacher can follow a light touch training, lasting about 5 hours and delivered before their formulation of guidance advices in s.y. 2021/22.
The project involves 189 lower secondary scools in Italy (self-selected into the project): Each school enrolled teachers wotking with oth grade strudents and the ones in charge of guidance at the organizational level.
We randomize the schools participating in the project: 98 schools are assigned to the first shift in the school year 2021/22; the other 91 schools are temporarily assigned to the condition of control group and their accesso to the training is postponed to the school year 2022/23.
At the end beginning of school year 2022/23, we will be able to assess the impact of our proferssional development on the primary outcome, namely the net association (meaning after controlling for students' performance) between students' social background (parental education and social class, mirgatory condition and gender) and the advice provided them by their teachers.
In addition, we will be able to follow up students along thier education career in the next school years, to assess whethere the advice will be followed and with which results in tems of education performance.
Before the intervention, to all the enrolled teachers we administered a questionnaire, collecting information and engagint them in a simulation case of guidance advice formulation. We hope to be able to collect the follow up questionnaire both on treatment and control group teachers, in order to assess the intervention impacts also at teachers level.

Intervention

We provide to lower secondarys school teachers' the opportunity to attend a professional development course focused on school guidance and providing them both awareness about related social inequalities and tips regarding how to reduce their potential biases.
The intervention is delivered though a dedicated web platform, where each teacher can follow a light touch training, lasting about 5 hours and delivered before their formulation of guidance advices in s.y. 2021/22.
Before the intervention, to all the enrolled teachers we administered a questionnaire, collecting information and engagint them in a simulation case of guidance advice formulation. We hope to be able to collect the follow up questionnaire both on treatment and control group teachers, in order to assess the intervention impacts at teachers level.

Experimental design

The project involves 189 lower secondary scools in Italy (self-selected into the project): Each school enrolled teachers working with 8th grade strudents and the ones in charge of guidance at the organizational level.
We randomize the schools participating in the project: 98 schools are assigned to the first shift in the school year 2021/22; the other 91 schools are temporarily assigned to the condition of control group and their accesso to the training is postponed to the school year 2022/23.
The randomization was blocked on macro-region, urban size, school size (total of 12 blocks).

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization was done by a computer (Stata, random function) and was implemented by an external researcher (Giovanni Abbiati).
Randomization unit
Schools are the randomized clusters.
Clusters
189 schools
Observations
about 19,000 students about 1,300 teachers
Arms
98 schools assigned to the treatment 91 schools assigned to the delayed treatment (control group in s.y. 2021/22)
Primary outcomes
At students level (end of s.y. 2021/22): we aspect that students assigned to treated teachers will display a school guidance advice less strongly associated to their social background (parental education and social class), migratory condition and gender, after controlling for students' performance. At students level (s.y. 2022/23 - beginning and end): we aspect that students assigned to treated teachers will enrol to school tracks with a lower associaton to their social background (parental education and social class), mirgatory condition and gender, after controlling for students' performance. At teachers level (end of s.y. 2021/22 - assuming to have a fair take up rate of our questionnaire among treatment and control group at teachers level, hence being able to estimate related impacts): we expect teachers in treatment group to display lower level of bias in formulating their advice to students in a vignette study.
Secondary outcomes
At techers' level: we expect treated teachers displaying higher self-efficacy related to their ability to formulate a correct advice and higher perception of being adequately informed about the upper seconday school offer in their region.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords