The Effect of Atheism Primes on Self-reported and and Implicit Religiosity
How to cite
Haushofer, Johannes; Reisinger, James. 2015. "The Effect of Atheism Primes on Self-reported and and Implicit Religiosity." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0000766. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.766-3.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
In recent years, atheism has grown in popularity, partly inspired by the rise to prominence of a group of public intellectuals called the “New Atheists” who argue against religion in public fora. Does exposure to the concept of atheism affect religiosity? We test in a laboratory study in Kenya whether exposure to arguments of the style made by the “New Atheists” impact selfreported and implicit religiosity measures. The present documents outlines the analyses to be conducted to answer this question.
Intervention
Manipulations
The primes used for the study consist of short video presentations (in English) and a writing task in which subjects are asked to summarize the main point of the primes. There are three conditions: emotional anti-religious argument, rational anti-religious argument, and control. Each prime is approximately 4 minutes long and consists of a speaker making various points about religion, or in the case of the control, about vegetables. The speaker is the same Kenyan narrator in all three videos. Bullet points summarizing the main arguments appear on the screen, accompanying the auditory presentation by the speaker. In the emotional condition, the speaker argues that any God must be very cruel if he allows so many people in the world to suffer, concluding that it is unlikely that God exists. In the rational condition, the speaker argues that the existence of God is unnecessary to explain the universe given our scientific knowledge. In the control condition, the same speaker instead argues that it is important to eat vegetables every day. After viewing the video presentations, participants are asked to summarize the main arguments in their own words by typing into a text box on their screen and then asked a series of questions to ensure comprehension. we will include analyses restricted based on comprehension as described below. The primes were randomly assigned within each session, with approximately 1/3 of participants in each condition. The setup of the lab included dividers between computers so that subjects were unaware of the images shown on the screens of others. Additionally, all subjects wore headphones, so they were unaware of what other participants were hearing. All images used in the implicit religiosity measure (described below) were vetted for comprehension by the experimenters and were further validated through debriefing after several pilot sessions.
Experimental design
1. Sampling
The study was conducted at the Busara Center for Behavioral Economics (Busara) in Nairobi, Kenya, a facility specially designed for social science studies. Busara maintains an active subject pool of more than 7,000 Nairobi residents. For the present study, 318 subjects who had previously signed-up to be part of the Busara subjet pool were recruited from local universities using SMS and phone calls and were informed that they would be paid KES 300 (approx. USD 7.20 PPP)1. Subjects were told that they were invited to participate in a study about their behavior and preferences. Recruitment was limited to university students to ensure comprehension of the arguments contained in primes. Restricting participation to University students also ensures comprehension English. Although Universities do not typically require an official test of English proficiency, matriculating students are expected to be proficient in written and spoken English, and much of the instruction is in English. Additionally, Busara has confirmed through previous studies that the vast majority of Kenyan university students are highly proficient in English. The sample includes 183 males and 133 females. All subjects were over 18 years of age, with a mean age of 22 and a maximum age of 26.
To control for heterogeneity in religious background, we restricted the sample to Christians by omitting individuals identified as ethnically Nubian from recruitment. Since most Muslims in the Busara subject pool belong to this ethnicity, we believed this to be the best way to identify Christians while avoiding any issues of self-selection that might arise by asking individuals their religion before participation. As described below, 24 individuals in the study either failed to report a religion identified as “no religion” or identified as “other,” and 2 individuals identified as Muslim. We will control for this fact by restricting our analysis as described below.
2. Experimental Procedure
After receiving a text message inviting them to participate in the study, individuals came to the Busara lab in Nairobi, Kenya, for experimental sessions lasting approximately one and half hours. Each session included up to 25 participants. Sessions were administered by two female Kenyan research assistants, who spoke English and Swahili fluently and were trained in helping subjects with comprehension. The experiment was conducted in English.
Subjects were randomly assigned to one of 25 computer workstations with partitions on three sides, so that they were unable to see or speak with the other subjects. Within each session, individuals were randomly assigned to one of the three conditions. All of the treatments and measures were implemented on HP TouchSmart 310 desktop computers running Windows 7. Each participant wore headphones and watched the video prime on his or her own computer. Subjects used the touch screen exclusively to mitigate effects of individual differences in experiences using a mouse and keyboard. All treatments were implemented using z-Tree software (Fischbacher 2007).
Each session progressed as follows:
1. Practice IAT
2. Cartoon ST-IAT
3. Nature ST-IAT
4. Video Prime (4 minutes)
5. Writing task and comprehension questions
6. Self-reported religiosity questionnaire
7. Practice IAT
8. Religion ST-IAT
9. Cantril ladder
10. WVS tolerance questionnaire
11. PANAS questionnaire
12. Demographics survey
At the conclusion of the final questionnaire, participants were debriefed and paid KES 300 in cash.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.