Behavioral responses to credit repayment: the effect of messages and renegotiations offers

How to cite

Barboni, Giorgia; Roux, Nicolás de; Campo, Juan Camilo Cardenas. 2021. "Behavioral responses to credit repayment: the effect of messages and renegotiations offers." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0007658. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7658-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Giorgia Barboni* , Nicolás de Roux , Juan Camilo Cardenas Campo

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0007658
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7658-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2021-05-03 – 2021-12-06
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/7658

Abstract

This project aims to offer clues on the behavioral motives that affect financial decision-making by individuals. We evaluate the randomized administration of behaviorally motivated SMS messages and renegotiation options implemented by a financial institution. The treatments will include behaviorally motivated texts intended to nudge non-business clients into debt repayment. Thus, our trial will test out the effectiveness of behaviorally motivated messages, the relative effectiveness of different behavioral motives and the interaction of these two elements with renegotiation options. This way, through randomization and a period of monitoring and follow-up on clients, this project hopes to identify the most effective behavioral motives for financial nudges in relation to repayment outcomes and to clients with varying levels of risk for financial institutions.

Intervention

The partner bank's clients are classified into three large intervention groups: up-to-date clients, low-risk defaulter clients, and high-risk defaulter clients with renegotiation possibilities. The three groups undergo different interventions: The first two receive behaviorally motivated messages that push towards repayment efforts, while the third group receives a combination of messages with renegotiation offers. Individuals are randomly selected to undergo different treatment (i. e. messages or renegotiation offers). Then, along the trial, clients keep on receiving the behaviorally motivated messages periodically until they step out of the group (become defaulters, for the case of the first group, or up-to-date clients, for groups 2 and 3). Herein, repayment rates are constantly measured to evaluate short-term and medium-term effects of the treatments on behavior.

Experimental design

Clients are classified according to their characteristics and the status of their relationship with the bank into three groups: low-risk defaulter clients and up-to-date clients. Each group of clients will undergo a separate intervention. Then, within the groups clients are randomly assigned to the different treatment branches and control groups for each intervention.
On the one side, interventions 1 and 2 have the objective of raising repayment rates on clients by sending behaviorally motivated SMS messages. Clients will be distributed among the different behavioral themes that build up the messages and the control groups. The messages will be sent throughout a period of 3 months, the duration of the trial for these clients. At the end, we will assess the impact of different behavioral motives on the clients' repayment rate.
On the other side, intervention 3 has the objective of evaluating the impact of renegotiation options and their interaction with behaviorally motivated SMSs. Clients will be distributed among both behavioral themes and types of renegotiation offers. Afterwards, they will be followed up and observed during a seven-month period to finally assess the impact of their particular treatments and the take-up of the renegotiation offers.

Design details

Randomization method
We randomize stratifying by the credit score the clients hold within the bank and the group of clients the banks classifies them into. Then, we use SQL random number generators to order clients randomly and select the higher-ups from the population in the strata to treatment groups.
Randomization unit
Individual level
Clusters
-
Observations
Intervention 1: 8,000 Intervention 2: 9,000 Intervention 3: 15,000
Arms
Clients will be assigned into groups consisting of a thousand people. These groups will receive a different treatment each. The third intervention remains to be fixed.
Primary outcomes
The study is mainly interested in repayment behavior. Thus, the primary outcome of interest is the repayment rates of the bank's customers. This will be the primary outcome for the interventions on defaulting clients. Conversely, the default rates are also an interesting variable of interest and will be the main outcome of interest for the case of up-to-date clients (group two).
Secondary outcomes
Secondary outcomes relate to the clients' perception of the bank. At the end of the trial, we will observe if treatment groups have a differentiated perception of it relative to control groups. The items of interest in relation to client perception follow on the themes we delve into with our treatments.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords