Personal Experiences and Political Views among Nepalese Politicians

How to cite

Fiorin, Stefano. 2021. "Personal Experiences and Political Views among Nepalese Politicians." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0007654. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7654-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Stefano Fiorin*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0007654
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7654-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2021-03-01 – 2022-12-31
Countries
Nepal ()
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/7654

Abstract

We recruit local politicians in Nepal for a phone survey to test whether their personal experiences, and especially participation in the Nepal People’s War, affect their political views and policy priorities. First, participants are randomized into three groups: i) participants in the control group are not asked to reflect on the link between their personal experiences and policy priorities; ii) participants in the “personal experiences prime” treatment group are asked to reflect on how their personal experiences affect their policy priorities, without any specific mention of the civil war; and finally, iii) participants in the “civil war prime” treatment group are asked to reflect on their personal experiences during the civil war and how these affect their policy priorities. We then measure participants’ policy goals, preferences for redistribution, opinions over targeting strategies related to social protection (avoiding exclusion or inclusion errors, and use of in-kind versus cash transfers), support for federalism, and opinions about political inclusion, and test whether their political views and policy priorities are affected by the control recollection of past personal experiences.

Experimental design

We ask local politicians and bureaucrats from Nepal to participate in a phone survey. Participants are recruited from a sample of 746 municipalities: in each municipality, we attempt to interview the mayor, the deputy mayor, and the chief administrative officer.

After obtaining participation consent, we ask all respondents a few demographic questions and a set of questions designed to measure their political ideology.

Afterwards, we randomize the controlled recollection of personal experiences during the civil war by randomizing participants into three groups. The first group, comprising a pure control, receives no prime at all. The second group (group 2, or “personal experiences prime” treatment group) receives the following prime: “Over your lifetime, you saw Nepal going through a lot of change. Can you please take a moment to share with us how those experiences shape your policy priorities now that you are a policy maker?”. The third group (group 3, or “personal experiences prime” treatment group) receives the prime: “Over your lifetime, you saw Nepal going through a lot of change. Please reflect on your personal experiences during the civil war. Can you please take a moment to share with us how those experiences shape your policy priorities now that you are a policy maker?” We developed these primes in close consultation with staff at the National Administrative Staff College and through informal discussions with politicians. Discussing experiences during the war, especially for public officials, is common and does not typically constitute a sensitive subject.

Before proceeding with the measurement of our outcomes of interest, all participants are truthfully informed about international donors’ involvement in the research project. We developed our questionnaire in close collaboration with policy partners, including the Foreign and Commonwealth Development Office (FCDO), and made sure they are comfortable with signing up to using the information to align their programming with mayors’ policy priorities. Specifically, we use the language: “In developing some of the following questions, we consulted with international donors who are looking to align their development assistance more closely with your needs. We will communicate the anonymized results of the survey to them and other development actors. Therefore, when responding, we ask that you take into consideration the fact that your responses might have some effect on donor priorities. Of course, all results will be communicated to donors only in anonymous and aggregate form, so your identity and your personal details will remain confidential and will not be linked to your responses.”
The purpose of emphasizing this to respondents is that it alleviates potential concerns of experimenters’ demand effect by increasing the real stakes of participants’ answers.

Next, participants are asked to express their opinion on: i) their own policy goals and their preferences over the policy goals of donors, ii) their priorities over eliminating errors of inclusion or exclusion from public programs, iii) their preferences for cash versus in-kind social protection payments; iv) their preferences for redistribution; v) their support for federalism; and vi) the inclusion of marginalized groups into policy decisions.

Next, all participants are asked a series of questions related to the COVID19 pandemic, that are not directly related to the project described here. Finally, all participants are also asked questions about their political party affiliation and plans for the next election.

Nepal’s people’s war, fundamentally, reflected a social movement to remove a caste-based monarchy and to allow groups who were historically denied political voice greater political representation. The fundamental hypothesis that we would like to test, therefore, is whether and the extent to which the struggle for greater rights during a social movement influences the policy priorities of politicians after they gain power and authority. In particularly, we are interested in whether those who fought for greater rights for historically excluded groups also, then, pursue more pro-poor policies that they have authority over.

A comparison of groups 1 and 2 allows us to test whether the recollection of any type of personal experience during Nepal’s transformation from a monarchy to a federal republic (which spanned the period 1990 - 2017) shapes policy priorities. A comparison of groups 1 and 3 allows a test of whether experiences specifically related to the civil war (which spanned the period 1996 - 2006) shapes these priorities. Finally, a comparison of groups 2 and 3 permits a test of how specific experiences during the civil war impact policy priorities relative to more general changes over the period.

Design details

Randomization method
The randomization is done through Stata.
Randomization unit
The unit of randomization is the individual participant. In assigning treatment, we plan to stratify on the following variables. First, position (mayor, deputy mayor, and CAO) to ensure power to test whether experiences are different in different subgroups. Because most mayors are men and most deputy mayors are women, this creates de facto stratification on gender. Second, region (plains/Terai, hill, Himalaya). Politics is highly regional in Nepal, with the Terai having its own struggles, and so we want to stratify by the region of the municipality to guarantee power for subgroup analysis by region. Finally, we stratify mayors and deputy mayors by party (Maoist, United Marxist Leninist, Nepali Congress, and other). We predict that treatment will be localized to respondents who participated directly in the struggle for greater rights, and this group is concentrated among the Maoists. CAOs are bureaucratic, not elected positions, and so we do not stratify them by party.
Clusters
The treatment is not clustered.
Observations
We will attempt to contact a total of 2224 participants.
Arms
We will attempt to contact 740 participants in group 1, 742 in group 2, and 742 in group 3.
Primary outcomes
The main objective of our experimental design is to measure the effect of the controlled recollection of personal experiences, especially during the civil war, on local politicians’: focus on pro-poor policies (with respect to their own policy goals and the policy goals of donors); priorities over eliminating errors of inclusion or exclusion from public programs; preferences for cash versus in-kind social protection payments; preferences for redistribution; support for federalism; beliefs about the current inclusion of marginalized groups into policy decisions, and about which excluded groups need to be included more in policy decisions.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords