Spouses’ Relative Influence in Household Decision-Making: Does decision domain make a difference?

How to cite

Jeppsson, Louise. 2021. "Spouses’ Relative Influence in Household Decision-Making: Does decision domain make a difference?." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0007638. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7638-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Louise Jeppsson*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0007638
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7638-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2021-05-06 – 2021-10-25
Countries
Viet Nam (Mekong River Delta)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/7638

Abstract

In a lab-in-the-field experiment I investigate to what extent spouses’ relative influence in household decision-making differ across decision domain. The sample consists of couples in rural Vietnam. In the experiment, spouses make individual and joint decisions with respect to an investment decision and a voluntary contribution decision to a local social fund for poor households in the village. I collect a rich set of household and individual characteristics as well as measures of beliefs and knowledge. I use the survey data collected to explore what background characteristic that determine spouses relative influence and to what extent these factors differ across decision domains. Of specific interest are measures of spouses’ responsibility for the household’s social relations constructed by a set of self-reported survey answers.

Additional results from the study will include an analysis of the association between self-reported measures of relative influence in household decision-making and my experimental measures collected in the experiment.

Intervention

This study does not consider a randomized intervention. This is a lab-in-the-field study where the intervention is a decision-making experiment with spouses to measure relative influence in different decision domains.

The main question of this study is whether spouses’ relative influence in household decision-making differs between decision domains; in this study an investment decision and a household contribution decision. The investment decision concern an investment in a lottery and the contribution decision concern a voluntary contribution to a local social fund for poor households in the village to enjoy next years TET holiday. Decisions are monetary incentivized. Furthermore, this study investigate what socioeconomic factors that determine relative influence in household decision-making. Specifically, if the importance of socioeconomic factors differ between decision domains.

All included couples in the study will first make two individual experimental decisions and then make the same two experimental decisions jointly.

In the individual investment decision subjects receive a personal endowment of 115 000 VND and decide what amount ‘e’ he/she wants to invest in a lottery. If the subject wins the lottery, he/she receives twice the amount invested. If the subject loses the lottery, the investment he/she made is lost and the subject only receives the (115 000-e) VND he/she decided not to invest. The investment decision is first made individually and then jointly. In the joint decision the spouses must agree to make the same investment in the lottery.

In the individual contribution decision the subjects are informed that the household receives an endowment of 115 000 VND and the subjects decide the amount "e" of the household endowment to voluntary contribute to a social fund for the poor households in the village. The amount contributed to the social fund will be multiplied by 1.2 in the experiment. The poor households in the village will receive a cash donation from the social fund ahead of next year’s TET celebration. Prior to making the decision participants are informed about the total number of households in his/her village that are included in the study and hence will make the same contribution decision. Subjects are also informed about the approximate number of households in the village that are classified as poor and hence will be the beneficiaries of the social fund. The contribution decision is first made individually where each spouse makes an individual decision about what amount of the household endowment he/she want to contribute on behalf of the household. The amount not contributed to the social fund is split equally between the spouses. In the following joint decision, spouses must agree on the amount of the household endowment of 115 000 VND that they want to contribute.

The order of the investment and contribution decision in the experiment is randomized at the household level. This is an attempt to alleviate concerns that my experimental measures of domain specific relative influence in household-decision making will be biased due to order effect and turns taking in the experimental decisions.

Experimental design

The study will be conducted with couples in two separate villages in the Mekong River Delta, Vietnam. From each village 108 households are randomly selected from the Vietnam Census 2019 data. Enumerators collect the data in selected households in teams of two enumerators, one female enumerator and one male enumerator. The study is conducted in respondents’ home and consist of different parts, the order of the different parts is fixed for all households and include the following:

01) Pre-study questions: Check experience of lotteries, experience of voluntary contributions to the village social fund for the poor and social distance to such social fund beneficiaries in the village as well as comprehension of probabilities. (spouses answer separately)
1) Incentivized Knowledge quiz: Measure knowledge about previous voluntary contribution to social funds for poor households to enjoy the TET holiday in the village. (spouses answer separately)
2) Individual survey: Demographic questions, questions about household members responsibility for the households social relations, questions about household-decision making across decision domains. (spouses answer separately)
3) Experiment Individual decisions: Order of investment and contribution decision is randomized at the household level. Detailed information below. (spouses answer separately)
4) Incentivized Guesses about spouse’s individual decisions. Respondent make guesses about the spouse’s individual decisions in previous experimental part. (spouses answer separately)
5) Experiment Joint decisions: Same order of experimental decision as in the individual experimental decisions. Detailed information below. (spouses answer together)
6) Household survey: Demographic questions. (spouses answer together)
7) Determine payment relevant choices. (Both spouses present)

Experiment design individual decisions (Part 3) and Joint decisions (Part 5):
All subjects make one individual decision and one joint decision with respect to two different decision domain; an investment decision, which concern an investment in a lottery, and a voluntary contribution decision to a local social fund for poor households in the village to enjoy next years TET holiday.

For the investment decision in Part 3 (Experiment Individual decision) subjects receive a personal endowment of 115 000 VND and decide what amount "e" he/she want to invest in a lottery. If the subject wins the lottery, he/she receive twice the amount invested. If the subject loses the lottery, the investment he/she made is lost and the subject only receive the (115 000-e) VND he/she decided not to invest. The investment decision is first made individually and then jointly in Part 5. In the joint decision the spouses must agree to make the same investment in the lottery.

For the contribution decision in Part 3 (Experiment Individual decision) the subjects are informed that the household receives an endowment of 115 000 VND and the subjects decide the amount "e" of the household endowment to voluntary contribute to a social fund to the poor households in the village. The amount contributed to the social fund will be multiplied by 1.2 in the experiment. The poor households in the village will receive a cash donation from the social fund ahead of next year’s TET celebration. Prior to making the decision participants are informed about the approximate number of households in his/her village that are included in the study and hence will make the same contribution decision. Subjects are also informed about the number of households in the village that are classified as poor and hence will be the beneficiaries of the social fund. The contribution decision is first made individually where each spouse makes an individual decision about the amount of the household endowment he/she want to contribute on behalf of the household. The amount not contributed to the social fund is split equally between the spouses. In the following joint decision in Part 5, spouses must agree what amount of the household endowment of 115 000 VND that they want to contribute.

The order for which the investment and contribution decision is presented in the experiment is randomized at the household level in an attempt to alleviate concerns that my experimental measures of domain specific relative influence will be biased due to order effect and turns taking the experimental decisions.

After participants has finalized the last part of the survey, enumerators randomly draw which decisions in the experimental parts are randomly selected for payment using bags with balls in different colors. For the investment decision, subjects will get payment either from their individual decisions or from their joint decision. For the contribution decision, subject will get payed either from the husband’s individual decision, the wife’s individual decision or from the joint decision.

To inform the decision of the study, survey material and experimental material pre-testing with students and small field pilots with coupes was conducted in Dec 2020- Jan 2021 (1 pre-testing with students & 2 small field pilots) as well as April 2021 (1 pre-testing with students & one small field pilot).

Design details

Randomization method
A computer randomly select the sample of household from the pool of married households in the Vietnamese Census 2019 data. Adding to that, a replacement list of households are randomly sampled. Whenever a household in the original sample of included households decline participation, are absent during the time period of the data collection or have divorced this household will be replaced by a replacement household in the list of replacement households. Replacement is stratified by age since pre-testing of the experiment in the field (conducted in January 2021) suggested that previous replacement procedure induced over-representation of households with older spouses.
Randomization unit
Household
Clusters
Not relevant
Observations
216 households (implies 432 participating subjects). All subjects make both the investment and contribution decision.
Arms
216 households (implies 432 participating subjects). All subjects make both the investment and contribution decision.
Primary outcomes
The key outcomes are the following: a) Relative influence in investment decision b) Relative influence in contribution decision c) Difference between domain specific relative influence in household decision–making
Secondary outcomes
Key explanatory variable: a) Responsibility for the household’s social relations Other key variables collected: b) Knowledge difference voluntary contribution decision c) Beliefs about spouse's individual decisions d) Social distance to beneficiaries of the social fund e) Most risk averse spouse

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords