Motivating students with successful endings: effect of hopeful role model stories on primary and secondary school pupils in Naples.

How to cite

Ghisolfi, Selene; Dimastrochicco, Raffaella. 2021. "Motivating students with successful endings: effect of hopeful role model stories on primary and secondary school pupils in Naples.." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0007628. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7628-3.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Selene Ghisolfi* , Raffaella Dimastrochicco

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0007628
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7628-3.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2021-05-03 – 2021-12-22
Countries
Italy (Campania)
JEL codes
j24 I25 I21 O15
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/7628

Abstract

Motivation, aspirations and self-esteem have been found to be important determinants of academic performance and, subsequently, of labour market outcomes. Students who do not believe in their ability to succeed may exert little effort, display lower cognitive skills or interact differently with their peers, severely hampering their final achievements. Interventions featuring positive role models have been found effective in raising student's aspirations and, eventually, their academic achievements, and movies conveying hopeful messages are specifically effective on the most disadvantaged students. In this experiment, we test the effect of a short motivational video, where a role model describes their difficult initial condition and their happy ending, on primary and secondary school students' outcomes such as effort, cognitive abilities, prosocial behavior, optimism, and aspirations. Additionally, we test if the gender of the role model matters for the impact, and specifically if the effects are larger for students watching a video with a gender-concordant role model. The experiment is set in one school in Naples, Italy, and involves 400 students of low socio-economic background. All students will be randomized in three treatment arms: students in the first treatment arm will watch a video where a role model of their same gender describe how, starting from a situation of difficulty, s/he managed to succeed in life by finding and pursuing his/her passions. Students in the second treatment arm are shown a similar motivational video featuring a role model of the opposite gender of the respondent. Students in the control group will all watch a video where a gender-concordant role model thanks them for their time in answering to the subsequent survey.

Intervention

The experiment is meant to capture the effect of a motivational video on elementary and middle school students in Naples, Italy. The intervention consists of one 30 second "role model" video, randomly chosen between 4 videos recorded. Each video features one role model only, which speaks directly to the student: in the Control video, the role model merely thanks the student for the participation in the survey, while in the Treatment video the role model describes how, starting from a situation of difficulty, they managed to succeed in life by finding and pursuing their passions.
The role models are one young man and one young woman from Naples who migrated in Italy from other countries. We chose them to be as similar as possible to the target students, as most students in the study are children of immigrant families. All videos are made by the role models using their phones, following a prepared script for comparability. We therefore use 4 videos: two Treatment videos, one made by the female and one by the male role model, and two Control videos, one made by the female and one by the male role model. Which video is shown to each students is randomly chosen as explained below.

Experimental design

The study is set in one school of Naples. The school has been chosen as it is located in a disadvantaged area and has many students with low socio economic background. All 460 students in the school will be asked to participate in the study. All consenting students will be randomized with equal probabilities in one of three treatment groups: the Control group in which each student will be shown the Control video featuring the role model of their own gender, and two Treatment groups: the same-gender treatment group, where the students will see the treatment video made by the role model of their own gender, and the different-gender treatment group, where the students will see the treatment video made by the role model of a different gender.

Design details

Randomization method
The randomization is done in the office using a computer and the program Stata. The students are pre-randomized into treatment groups.
Randomization unit
individual randomization
Clusters
460 students
Observations
460 students
Arms
150 students in the control group, 155 students in the same-gender Treatment, 155 in the different-gender Treatment.
Primary outcomes
The primary outcomes are student's effort, cognitive ability, expectations of own performance relative to peers, trust and altruism toward peers, aspirations regarding schooling and future jobs, confidence and self-esteem, and academic performance.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords