An experimental test on the causal effect of moral self-concept on university students’ cheating behavior – pre-registration of a study design
How to cite
Keller, Tamas. 2021. "An experimental test on the causal effect of moral self-concept on university students’ cheating behavior – pre-registration of a study design." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0007613. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7613-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We pre-register a large-scale experiment to test the direct causal effect of moral self-concept on fraudulent behavior (cheating). We follow the theoretical considerations of self-concept maintenance theory [SCMT], which describes mechanisms that allow people to enjoy the benefits of cheating and still maintain a positive self-concept. Following the logic of SCMT’s attention-to-standards mechanism, we hypothesize that if people are mindful of their moral standards, they cheat less since cheating triggers downgrading of people’s moral self-concept, which they aim to avoid. We will measure students’ cheating using the die-under-the-cup task. We employ a narrow definition of moral self-concept, which rests on the self-reported honesty that we externally induce by a random intervention. Our light-touch pre-tested intervention consists of an affirmation message that empowers students’ moral self-concept. Under the assumption that the intervention affects the outcome only via self-concept, we interpret the intervention as an instrumental variable for the causal effect of self-reported honesty. Therefore, we can directly test the hypothesized negative causal effect between self-concept and cheating that prior research has assessed through indirect and non-causal mediation analysis. Confirmed hypotheses will indicate that moral self-concept has a direct negative effect on cheating. Falsified hypotheses will suggest that our narrowly defined, externally induced, and self-reported moral self-concept does not prevent people from cheating. Thus, researchers should find out different experimental settings to explore the causal effect of moral self-concept on fraudulent behavior within the framework of SCMT.
Intervention
Half of the students are randomly assigned to the treated group based on the value of a random number. The remaining half of the students are assigned to the control group.
We manipulate students’ moral self-concept through positive affirmation messages that empower students’ honesty with a language praising and acknowledging students’ honesty. Treated students receive the affirmation message, and control students do not.
Experimental design
The experimental setting contains the following four steps:
1. random manipulation of moral self-concept [self-reported honesty]
2. measuring self-reported honesty
3. making moral standards accessible to people by strengthening the link between self-concept and cheating
4. tempting students and measuring their engagement with fraudulent behavior
We provide a direct test of how self-concept affects cheating. By doing so, we provide an experimental random manipulation (treatment) of people’s self-concept. We interpret the randomized treatment as an instrument that affects cheating via self-concept. Thus, based on some recent work (Sobel, 2008), we turn to instrumental variable estimation to investigate self-concept maintenance as a causal mechanism that affects cheating.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.