The Role of Subjective Perceptions in Health Decisions: A Field Experiment among Disadvantaged Youth

How to cite

Crepon, Bruno; Pernaudet, Julie. 2016. "The Role of Subjective Perceptions in Health Decisions: A Field Experiment among Disadvantaged Youth." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0000761. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.761-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Bruno Crepon* , Julie Pernaudet

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0000761
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.761-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2011-01-01 – 2013-01-01
Countries
France ()
JEL codes
I12, I13, J24 D83
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/761

Abstract

Disadvantaged youth are particularly at risk of under-investing in their health. Costs of healthcare and bias in health needs perceptions are likely to be key factors of under-investment. Relying on a randomized experiment, we find that providing them with personalized information both on public health insurance and on their health status based on a medical diagnosis raises their curative and preventive investments. More specifically, they are more likely to consult a psychologist and to use contraception, while depression and risky sexual behaviors are key issues in this population. In order to distinguish between the two barriers, financial constraints and underestimation of health needs, we also test a program providing information on public health insurance only. This limited program improves their level of medical coverage in the same way as the combined program, but it does not translate into higher health investments. These findings highlight the importance of taking into account the role of subjective perceptions of health needs when considering health decisions among disadvantaged youth.

Intervention

The experiment tests two interventions.
The first intervention consists in encouraging young people to meet individually a social worker, whose role is to check their medical coverage is complete (basic and complementary insurance), up to date and adequate with their economic situation (typically, many young people are eligible to Universal Health Care coverage (CMU or CMU-C) and they do not know it) and in case it is not, explain to the young person how to update or change it and make sure she does it. The social worker also has to explain to the young person her rights and the functioning of her medical coverage, especially reimbursement procedures. The aim is that the youth who meet the social worker can afford health care at the end of the intervention and also know they can afford it.
The second intervention consists in encouraging young people to see both the social worker and a doctor whose role is to make an individualized diagnosis of the state of health of the young people and make recommendations on the practitioner(s) to consult if need be, but the doctor in the intervention is not allowed to provide care or prescriptions, he can just direct young people to one practitioner or another. The doctor also has to provide information on health care, on health centers, on what to do in case of one symptom or another. The aim is that youth who meet the doctor become aware of their health needs, informed on the ways to meet these needs and feel more familiar with medicine and care. Another dimension of the doctor intervention concerns risk behavior. The doctor was supposed to assess, based on various questions, health behavior such as tobacco, alcohol or drug use, as well as sexual behavior.
Both interventions are entrusted to experts and are individualized in order to make young people believe in the information provided and feel concerned about it.

Experimental design

The design consists in a two-arm treatment with random assignment of individuals in each of the two treatments or in the control group.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer.
Randomization unit
Individual randomization.
Clusters
5 job centers: Mission locale de Sénart Mission locale de la Dhuys Mission locale de Reims Mission locale de Poitiers Mission locale de Toulouse
Observations
1528 young people in the baseline survey, 1100 young people in the follow-up survey.
Arms
501 young people in the social worker intervention. 532 young people in the social worker + doctor intervention. 495 young people in the control group.
Primary outcomes
1. Level of medical coverage and understanding of procedures 2. Health care utilization and health practices 3. Health status 4. Employment

Papers from this trial

  1. Le projet PresaJe est né du constat, chez les jeunes les plus en difficultés, d’un faible recours aux soins, en dépit d’un état de santé dégradé susceptible de porter préjudice à leur insertion … http://www.experimentation.jeunes.gouv.fr/IMG/pdf/RE_AP2_076_EVA_RF_201404-2.pdf

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords