Enabling Sustainable Graduation out of Poverty for the Extreme Poor in Malawi: The Role of Gender Targeting and Couples Training.

How to cite

Bedi, Tara; Vaillant, Julia; King, Michael; Ramos, Alejandra. 2021. "Enabling Sustainable Graduation out of Poverty for the Extreme Poor in Malawi: The Role of Gender Targeting and Couples Training.." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0007605. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7605-1.2

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Tara Bedi* , Julia Vaillant , Michael King , Alejandra Ramos

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0007605
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7605-1.2
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2018-06-01 – 2025-12-31
Countries
Malawi (Mangochi and Nsanje )
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/7605

Abstract

This study will assess the effect of the Graduation model in Malawi on gender empowerment and household welfare outcomes in married couples. The Graduation Model is a 'big push' intervention designed to move people out of poverty by addressing the many challenges of extreme poverty by simultaneously boosting livelihoods and income and providing access to financial services. The Graduation program will be run over an 18 month period, with the first cohort receiving the program from November 2018 to June 2020, and the second one between October 2019 – June 2021. The research will estimate the impact of three distinct version of the graduation intervention, 1) the graduation program targeted at the female spouse, 2) the graduation program targeted at the male spouse and 3) the graduation program targeted at the female spouse but with an additional couple's empowerment training.

Intervention

The research is designed to address the gap on the role of gender in Graduation program outcomes. The research will estimate the impact of three distinct versions of the Graduation Model on gender empowerment and household welfare outcomes. The three proposed versions tested are as follows: 1) the graduation program targeted at women; 2) the graduation program targeted at men, and; 3) the graduation program targeted at women but with an additional couples’ empowerment training called ‘Transforming Gender & Power Relations’ that is rolled out through 12 monthly group sessions. Each intervention will be delivered to 600 households randomly selected in Mangochi and Nsanje, with 300 households in each district receiving each version of the proposed program. There will be an additional 750 households in each district who will act as control households.

The Graduation intervention in Malawi is a 18-month intense, multifaceted intervention but the research project will be spread over five years to allow for the estimation of medium term effects. The Randomized Control Trial (RCT) will rely on three rounds of a quantitative survey per cohort. A baseline (Q2 2018/19), midline (Q3 2020/21) and an endline (Q3 2021/22) survey will be conducted to capture key welfare measures, as well as important measures of empowerment, IPV and spousal cohesion. The quantitative research will be complemented by qualitative research.

Experimental design

Through the use of a poverty index, our implementing partner, Concern Worldwide, identified the two districts with the highest poverty score, Mangochi and Nsanje, for implementing the Graduation program in. Within this, they selected sub-districts (VDCs) that they would implement the program in. The pilot intervention will be evaluated using a clustered randomized controlled trial (RCT). The randomisation will be conducted at the village level, where Concern Worldwide will be implementing their Graduation program in.

Treatment villages are randomly allocated to one of three treatment options: 1) the graduation programme targeted at women; 2) the graduation program targeted at men, and; 3) the graduation program targeted at women but with an additional couples’ empowerment training called ‘Transforming Gender & Power Relations’. In treatment village, 12 eligible households will be randomly selected to receive treatment.

In order to be eligible, the households had to meet the following criteria:
• The household had to be classified as poor through a wealth ranking or a proxy means test.
• The household head is married and his spouse lives within the household
• Both head and spouse are willing and able to participate in an Income Generating Activity.
• Both head and spouse reside at the household at least 60% of the year.

In the final data collection round we conducted a measurement experiment testing an alternative sequencing of the intimate partner violence module that reverses the order of the lifetime and recent experiences of violence questions.

Design details

Randomization method
* Both village and household randomisation were done on a computer using Stata, a statistical software.
Randomization unit
We identified 200 villages, 100 per district, based on each village having at least 20 eligible households in the village. We then randomized across villages, assigning 50 villages as pure control villages and the remaining as treatment villages. After our baseline, we did our next round of randomization, which involved 3 steps. First, we randomized the treatment villages into the three treatment arms. Second, in treatment villages, we randomized 12 households to receive treatment, and the remaining 6 as control households. Third, we randomized all treatment and control villages into cohort 1 and cohort 2, with the first treatment cohort starting with the program in November 2018, and the cohort 2 starting in 2019. The updated module was randomly administered to half of the female respondents (individual-level randomization).
Clusters
200 villages
Observations
3300 households: 12 households in control villages, 12 treatment households and 6 control households in treatment villages In our final data collection round we no longer include spill-over households.
Arms
- 600 control households in 50 control villages - 600 treatment households plus 300 control households in 50 treatment 1 villages: Graduation targeted to the female spouse - 600 treatment households plus 300 control households in 50 treatment 2 villages: Graduation targeted to the male spouse - 600 treatment households plus 300 control households in 50 treatment 3 villages: Graduation targeted to the female spouse with couples training.
Primary outcomes
- Economic outcomes: income, savings, likelihood of being employed, time use, likelihood of having a business and business revenue, livestock ownership; - Well-being outcomes: well-being index, health, food security, consumption, education, social standing, future expectations; - Gender outcomes: intra-household decision making, empowerment, gender norms, relationship quality and intimate partner violence

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords