Can a Shared National Identity Trump Ethnic Identity? Evidence from a Field Experiment in Singapore

How to cite

RIAMBAU, Guillem; Toha, Risa. 2021. "Can a Shared National Identity Trump Ethnic Identity? Evidence from a Field Experiment in Singapore." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0007559. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7559-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Guillem RIAMBAU* , Risa Toha

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0007559
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7559-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2021-07-01 – 2022-12-31
Countries
Singapore ()
JEL codes
D91; J15.
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/7559

Abstract

Ethnic diversity has been widely associated with lower levels of social harmony. The main reason for this
is the proven existence of ethnic biases, which have been shown to impact romantic preferences, neighborhood choices, job recruitments, electoral votes, and political stability, among others. Oftentimes, however, the ethnic dimension cannot be easily disentangled from other dimensions of identity, such as class or nationality. Hence, the independent effect of ethnic diversity remains to be fully understood. This project aims to fill in this gap: by leveraging Singapore’s unique demographic composition, it aims to pin down the independent effect of ethnic, national and socioeconomic identities on social harmony. To be precise, the goal is to measure the extent to which they impact (if at all) pro-social, altruistic behavior. To do so, we conduct a field experiment, using the “misplaced envelope technique”. This consists of sending envelopes with valuables inside (in our case, a voucher) to the wrong addressee. The actual recipient, upon realizing that (s)he is not the intended recipient, can choose to keep the voucher or return it. By randomizing the ethnicity, nationality and socio-economic status of our actual and intended recipients, we can assess which dimensions trigger altruistic behavior (i.e., returning the voucher to the correct addressee) over others. Our study bears important contributions. Theoretically, uncovering how these different affiliations affect altruism will help us understand broader questions about the process through which national integration and social cohesion can be cultivated in a multiethnic context. Methodologically, to the best of our knowledge, our study will be the first to analyze this issue by using observed behavior, as opposed to survey data, hence overcoming social desirability biases that arise in surveys. In terms of policy, our findings should shed light on how social integration and cooperation across groups can be strengthened.

Intervention

The goal of this study is, by leverage Singapore’s unique demographic composition, to pin down the independent effect of ethnic, national and socioeconomic identities on pro-social, altruistic behavior. To do so, we conduct a field experiment, using the “misplaced envelope technique”. This consists of sending envelopes with valuables inside (in our case, a voucher) to the wrong addressee. The actual recipient, upon realizing that (s)he is not the intended recipient, can choose to keep the voucher or return it. By randomizing the ethnicity, nationality and socio-economic status of our actual and intended recipients, we can assess which dimensions trigger altruistic behavior (i.e., returning the voucher to the correct addressee) over others.

Experimental design

The experiment is based on the misaddressed letter technique. Residents will receive an envelope addressed to them. However, the letter (and token of appreciation) inside will be addressed to someone else (seemingly by mistake). We will examine which resident and addresse characteristics explain willingness to return the voucher to the (perceived as) correct addressee.

Design details

Randomization method
The raffle will be allocated via randomization done in office by a colleague computer. Randomization of misaddressed letters will be done via die roll taking into account that some quotas have to be met.
Randomization unit
The units of randomization will be individuals.
Clusters
(design not clustered).
Observations
3150 individuals receiving a letter
Arms
3150 individuals receiving a letter
Primary outcomes
Willingness to return the voucher

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords