Reciprocating Preferences in Matching Markets
How to cite
Opitz, Timm; Schwaiger, Christoph. 2021. "Reciprocating Preferences in Matching Markets." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0007551. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7551-2.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Matching markets intend to form mutually beneficial stable relationships. The stability criterion guarantees that no participant can benefit from breaking up a formed match. Under the deferred acceptance mechanism (DA), matches ought to be stable. This result builds on the assumptions of strict and invariable preference orders under complete information. Empirical evidence on whether preferences actually meet these assumptions is lacking. In a theory-guided laboratory experiment, we test whether agents have reciprocating preferences. We hypothesize that agents prefer to interact with someone who prefers interacting with them. Hence, agents adjust their own preference ranking once they know how other participants ranked them. We document how this affects the stability of the DA, investigate subsequent cooperation behavior in the formed teams and discriminate between belief-based and preference-based explanation for preference changes. This contributes to the literature on the design and robustness of (centralized) matching markets.
Intervention
We compare behavior under two information structures in a between-subject design In the baseline condition (No-Info), participants never know how their potential (and actual) partners rank them. In the treatment condition (Info), participants do receive the information how they are ranked before submitting their final preference list. This allows them to incorporate this information into their own preferences and gives them the option to adjust behavior in the PGG based on their knowledge of how much their partner wanted to do be matched with them.
Experimental design
The experiment consists of a team-formation process and a PGG that is played within the formed dyads. Teams are formed through a centralized matching mechanism. The underlying preferences of players are based on self-reported questionnaire information of the potential partners. After being matched with one of the potential partners, participants play the PGG with the (known) partner. During the team-formation process, players interact within matching groups. We study a setting of two-sided matching in a one-to-one market. Hence, half of the players within each matching group take the role of proposers, half the role of receivers. Within each experimental session, there will be multiple matching groups, each consisting of 8 participants. To increase statistical power, we reshuffle matching groups 4 times. No proposer will interact with the same receiver twice and vice versa. [Detailed information on the design can be found in the pre-analysis plan.]
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.