Improving agricultural productivity and resilience with cellphone imagery to scale climate-smart crop insurance

How to cite

Kramer, Berber; Cecchi, Francesco; Kivuva, Benjamin; Waithaka, Lilian. 2021. "Improving agricultural productivity and resilience with cellphone imagery to scale climate-smart crop insurance." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0007435. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7435-1.6

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Berber Kramer* , Francesco Cecchi , Benjamin Kivuva , Lilian Waithaka

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0007435
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7435-1.6
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2019-10-01 – 2023-12-31
Countries
Kenya (Bungoma, Busia, Embu, Machakos, Makeuni, Meru, Tharaka Nithi)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/7435

Abstract

Weather hazards such as erratic rainfall cause significant hardship for smallholder farmers in Kenya. Climate change is expected to further exacerbate farmers’ vulnerability to extreme weather. The anticipation of possible losses discourages farmers from making productivity-enhancing investments, trapping them in low-risk yet low-return agriculture. Agricultural insurance complemented with other risk-reducing practices is often cited as a sustainable approach to unlock investments in agriculture for smallholders, improving their resilience and productivity. Thus far, the number of successful insurance schemes targeting smallholders is limited, however, because of high monitoring and verification costs of traditional insurance, combined with low demand for index-based insurance—designed to eliminate the need to verify losses—mainly due to poor trust and basis risks (i.e. the imperfect correlation between farmers’ actual losses and insurance payouts). This project aims to overcome these problems through climate-smart picture-based insurance (PBI), which uses cellphone imagery to verify losses, observe management practices and promote the adoption of productivity-enhancing yet resilient technologies through bundling with stress-tolerant seeds. Ground pictures help reduce monitoring costs, minimize basis risks and create synergies with climate-smart resilience technologies. By taking pictures of insured crops, farmers engage directly in the insurance process, improving trust and tangibility. We measure the impacts of this approach by means of a cluster randomized trial in 7 counties from different regions in Kenya. We randomly assign local village entrepreneurs who provide farmers in their communities with insurance and seeds into one of three treatment arms: a) no insurance marketing efforts (control), b) marketing of the climate-smart PBI product (treatment), and c) marketing of a comparable index-based product that does not rely on smartphone pictures for claims settlement (placebo). We cross-randomize whether the village entrepreneurs provide only regular seeds, or also stress-tolerant cultivars that offer partial protection from extreme weather events.

Intervention

The project tests two interventions to improve agricultural risk management:

1. A new picture-based crop insurance (PBI) product that settles insurance claims based on visible damage in smartphone images of a farmer's crops, taken by so-called champion farmers from sowing to harvest, in order to reduce basis risk in crop insurance relative to a remotely measured weather index (provided free of charge to project farmers in the first four seasons of the project).

2. Marketing and other promotions by champion farmers of stress-tolerant varieties for targeted crops (maize, sorghum and green grams). Farmers in both treatment and control received trial packs of these varieties in the first and third season to raise awareness. The champion farmers are aggregating demand for these varieties in the treatment arm during the third and fourth season of the project.

Experimental design

Champions are randomly assigned to one of the following treatment arms:
1. Control: champion sends in images of crops for participating farmers but does not provide insurance
2. Weather index-based insurance: champion sends in images of crops for participating farmers and provides these farmers with weather index-based insurance for the crops that are visible in the cellphone images.
3. Picture-based insurance: champion sends in images of crops for participating farmers and provides these farmers with picture-based insurance that settles claims based on visible damage to the crops shown in the cellphone images.

We cross-randomize the type of seeds that champions provide: either regular seeds only, or also stress-tolerant seeds (in addition to any insurance products that they may offer). Specifically, within each treatment arm, 50% of champions are randomly assigned to provide regular seeds, with the remaining 50% also providing stress-tolerant varieties.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer (in STATA)
Randomization unit
We randomize at the level of the champion farmer (village entrepreneurs who are hired by ACRE Africa to provide services such as insurance products and seeds to farmers in their communities).
Clusters
We are planning to include 191 champion farmers.
Observations
We are planning to include about 15 farmers per champion farmer/cluster (total sample size of 2,880 farmers) in the survey (including the champion farmer him/herself).
Arms
We have the following numbers of champion farmers by treatment: - 80 champions control (36 providing regular seeds only, 44 also providing stress-tolerant varieties of seeds); - 40 champions with WBI (29 providing regular seeds only, 11 also providing stress-tolerant varieties of seeds); - 71 champions with picture-based insurance (35 providing regular seeds only, 36 also providing stress-tolerant varieties of seeds).
Primary outcomes
Insurance coverage; adoption of targeted stress-tolerant varieties; investments in other productive inputs and technologies; and labor use (both family and hired labor).
Secondary outcomes
Agricultural productivity; income per acre from target crops; seed and insurance demand; food consumption (diversity); resilience indicator based on repeat measures of food consumption; and women's empowerment in agriculture.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords