Navigating Performance Complexity in Public Service Delivery: Do Frontline Workers Distinguish Between Inputs, Outputs, and Outcomes?

How to cite

Hansen, Paw. 2021. "Navigating Performance Complexity in Public Service Delivery: Do Frontline Workers Distinguish Between Inputs, Outputs, and Outcomes?." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0007418. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7418-1.2

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Paw Hansen*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0007418
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7418-1.2
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2021-04-06 – 2021-04-27
Countries
Denmark ()
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/7418

Abstract

We provide descriptions of fictive high schools to a large sample of Danish high-school teachers and ask them to rate the outcome attainment of the presented schools.

Within each description, we randomly assign a number of different pieces information about outcomes: socioeconomic mobility, wellbeing, and transition to higher education. In addition, we provide teachers with information about schools' "production attributes", i.e. the inputs and outputs preceding outcomes.

For organizational inputs, we use two sets of wordings related to student backgrounds—one tied to student origin (e.g., “Has a high proportion of students with a non-Western background.”) and the other linked to parents’ educational background (e.g., “Has a high proportion of parents without higher education.”).

For organizational outputs, we use two distinct sets of wordings—one focusing on past efforts (e.g., “Has implemented many initiatives to improve quality in the past year.”) and the other on potential future efforts (e.g., “Significant focus on developing the teaching in the future.”).

Intervention

We provide descriptions of fictive high schools to a large sample of Danish high-school teachers and ask them to rate the outcome attainment of the presented schools.

Within each description, we randomly assign a number of different pieces information about outcomes: socioeconomic mobility, wellbeing, and transition to higher education. In addition, we provide teachers with information about schools' "production attributes", i.e. the inputs and outputs preceding outcomes.

For organizational inputs, we use two sets of wordings related to student backgrounds—one tied to student origin (e.g., “Has a high proportion of students with a non-Western background.”) and the other linked to parents’ educational background (e.g., “Has a high proportion of parents without higher education.”).

For organizational outputs, we use two distinct sets of wordings—one focusing on past efforts (e.g., “Has implemented many initiatives to improve quality in the past year.”) and the other on potential future efforts (e.g., “Significant focus on developing the teaching in the future.”).

Experimental design

We provide descriptions of fictive high schools to a large sample of Danish high-school teachers and ask them to rate the outcome attainment of the presented schools.

Within each description, we randomly assign a number of different pieces information about outcomes: socioeconomic mobility, wellbeing, and transition to higher education. In addition, we provide teachers with information about schools' "production attributes", i.e. the inputs and outputs preceding outcomes.

For organizational inputs, we use two sets of wordings related to student backgrounds—one tied to student origin (e.g., “Has a high proportion of students with a non-Western background.”) and the other linked to parents’ educational background (e.g., “Has a high proportion of parents without higher education.”).

For organizational outputs, we use two distinct sets of wordings—one focusing on past efforts (e.g., “Has implemented many initiatives to improve quality in the past year.”) and the other on potential future efforts (e.g., “Significant focus on developing the teaching in the future.”).

We have two primary outcomes: 1) The probability that schools with certain characteristics are chosen as highest performing, and 2) the rating respondents assign to each school.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is done by computer.
Randomization unit
Approx. 9,000 high school teachers
Clusters
Approx. 9,000 high school teachers
Observations
Approx. 2,500 high school teachers x 3 matched pairs = 7,500 choices and 15,000 ratings.
Arms
Approx. 1/3 in each arm = 833 high school teachers in each arm.
Primary outcomes
We have two primary outcomes: 1) The probability that schools with certain characteristics are chosen as highest performing, and 2) the rating respondents assign to each school.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords