Teachers and Deserving Students

How to cite

Hansen, Paw. 2021. "Teachers and Deserving Students." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0007410. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7410-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Paw Hansen*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0007410
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7410-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2021-04-06 – 2021-04-27
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/7410

Abstract

We present a large sample of Danish high-school teachers with four distinct vignette descriptions of fictive dilemmas with students. We randomly manipulate a number of student attributes and examine how these relate to teachers' choices in each dilemma.

Intervention

Interventions are different pieces of information about the students in the four different fictive dilemmas. The dilemmas examine whether teachers would be willing to (a) stay after class to help with an assignment, (b) discuss an assignment over the phone in the weekend, (c) allow a student to hand-in an assignment after deadline, and, finally, (d) push the deadline for a hand-in one week to accommodate a student.

Interventions are the same across all four dilemmas. We hypothesize, based on previous literature, that receiving some pieces of information will trigger a sense of student deservingness and consequently cause teachers to "move towards" students, e.g. by being willing to stay after class to discuss an assignment. Specifically, our interventions are information about the student's: (1) effort the previous school year, (2) effort recently, (3) academic achievement, and (4) social achievement class. In addition, for contextual realism, we provide a name for each student. Names differ in terms of sex and ethnicity.

Experimental design

Our primary outcomes of interest is how teachers reply in each of four dilemmas concerning interactions with students. Specifically, we ask teachers how willing they would be on a 10-point scale to: (a) stay after class to help with an assignment, (b) discuss an assignment over the phone in the weekend, (c) allow a student to hand-in an assignment after deadline, and, finally, (d) push the deadline for a hand-in one week to accommodate a student.

Interventions are different pieces of information about the students in the four different fictive dilemmas. We employ the same groups of information across all dilemmas. We hypothesize, based on previous literature, that receiving some pieces of information will trigger a sense of student deservingness and consequently cause teachers to "move towards" students. The design is conjoint so all pieces of information are given simultaneously. Specifically, our interventions are information about the student's: (1) effort the previous school year, (2) effort recently, (3) academic achievement, and (4) social achievement class. In addition, for contextual realism, we provide a name for each student. Names differ in terms of sex and ethnicity.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is done with computer.
Randomization unit
Each respondent receives all four dilemmas. Within each dilemma, we randomly assign four pieces of information about student deservingness.
Clusters
Approx. 9,000 high school teachers.
Observations
Approx. 9,000 high school teachers.
Arms
For each treatment, approx. 4,500 teachers will receive a treatment, and approx. 4,500 will receive a control.
Primary outcomes
Our primary outcomes of interest is how teachers reply in each of the four dilemmas. Specifically, we ask teachers how willing they would be on a 10-point scale to: (a) stay after class to help with an assignment, (b) discuss an assignment over the phone in the weekend, (c) allow a student to hand-in an assignment after deadline, and, finally, (d) push the deadline for a hand-in one week to accommodate a student.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords