Morality-Efficiency Tradeoffs: An Experimental Study

How to cite

Macis, Mario; Lacetera, Nicola; Elias, Julio. 2015. "Morality-Efficiency Tradeoffs: An Experimental Study." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0000732. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.732-6.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Mario Macis* , Nicola Lacetera , Julio Elias

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0000732
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.732-6.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2015-08-03 – 2017-12-12
Countries
United States of America (NY), United States of America (NY), United States of America (NY)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/732

Abstract

In modern societies, certain activities and transactions are limited or prohibited on the basis of ethical considerations, even when the parties in these activities may benefit from an economic standpoint. Examples include payments for human organs for transplantation, prostitution, the performance of morally controversial research, and the commercialization of living organisms. The opposition to these activities rests in part on a desire to protect vulnerable people from exploitation or coercion. However, the aversion is often due to the idea that certain transactions would corrupt moral values. In this study, we propose and test a methodology to understand individuals’ attitudes toward ethically controversial transactions. Specifically, the goal of this study is to determine whether and how individuals make trade-offs between moral values and economic efficiency, and to estimate these preferences and their distribution in the population.

Intervention

To quantify the trade-offs between morality and economic efficiency, we will perform experimental survey studies with approximately 5,000 subjects recruited online and through professional survey firms. For a series of morally controversial transactions, we will present respondents with a set of alternative systems, randomly varying (a) whether some form of compensation to the "sellers" is allowed (e.g., monetary or in-kind payments to kidney donors), (b) whether allocation of the scarce resource (e.g., kidneys for transplantation) is based on market forces or decided by a government agency, and (c) the (estimated) gains for society associated with the various systems. We will then gauge the respondents' degree of moral concern and overall favor for the various systems. Then, we will obtain estimates, at the individual level, of marginal rates of substitution between "morality" and "efficiency".

Experimental design

Randomized controlled trial.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done by survey software (Qualtrics).
Randomization unit
Individual randomization.
Clusters
3000 individual mTurk respondents (Study 1) 2700 individual Qualtrics respondents (Study 2)
Observations
3000 respondents (mTurk sample) 2500 respondents (Qualtrics sample)
Arms
STUDY 1 The structure of our experiment produces 2 x 5^2 x 5^2 = 50 different triplets with efficiency information only expressed in terms of transplant, and as many triplets with added information on dollar savings, with three of which being assigned to each subject.With 3,000 subjects in total, and each individual having a chance of being assigned one particular triplet of about 3%, we expected about 90 observations on each of the 100 triplets. We also added one case (approximately 100 observations) where the subject is asked to choose one of the three systems with no information provided on the number of kidneys procured. STUDY 2 With 2,700 subjects and 16 experimental conditions, we expect to have about 168 subjects in each condition.
Primary outcomes
The key outcome variables are: (1) Degree of favor for alternative regulatory regimes for morally controversial transactions (e.g., procurement and allocation of organs for transplantation). (2) Choice between alternative regulatory regimes for morally controversial transactions (e.g., procurement and allocation of organs for transplantation). (3) Degree of moral concern associated with alternative regulatory regimes (e.g., concern for exploitation of the poor and vulnerable, coercion, respect for human dignity).

Materials

Papers from this trial

  1. Elías, Julio J., Nicola Lacetera, and Mario Macis. 2019. "Paying for Kidneys? A Randomized Survey and Choice Experiment." American Economic Review, 109 (8): 2855–88. https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/aer.20180568

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords