Earned and unearned income: Experimental evidence in Malawi
How to cite
Ambler, Kate; Godlonton, Susan. 2021. "Earned and unearned income: Experimental evidence in Malawi." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0007286. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7286-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Though the differential impacts of earned and unearned income have long been of interest to economists and policymakers, the study of this question is often conflated by other differences between the income streams. We conduct a field experiment in Malawi in which we examine the differential short-term effect of earned and unearned income on the allocation of expenditures and labor supply, holding all other factors constant. All participants receive an equal size cash payment and make the same time investment; half are required to work, and half are not.
Intervention
The sample is developed from a list of names and cell phone numbers of people who had sent remittances to farming families participating in a large study on agricultural extension and cash transfers. Following the survey, all the remitters named by farmers will be contacted and asked to participate in a short phone survey. At the end of the survey, all of the remitters will be notified that they will be contacted in several months and invited to a meeting where they will guaranteed the opportunity to earn additional money. Those migrants who choose to attend will be randomized into two groups: those who must earn the money through a temporary job and those who are simply given the money. We expect to offer approximately 10,000 Malawi Kwacha (around 20 USD), which is slightly more than the average yearly remittance total of approximately 8,500 Kwacha in our baseline data.
The first objective of this intervention then will be to determine if the participants spend the money differently when it is earned vs unearned. This will be measured in two ways. First, because remittances are a main focus of the study, two-thirds of the migrants will be offered the opportunity on the spot to remit a portion of their earnings to their families in their home location. Second, expenditures will tracked through brief expenditure surveys conducted with the migrant by phone at weekly intervals for one month after the payments are made. Third, we will measure labor supply to study whether work activity is affected.
The second objective will be to understand how recipient economic conditions affect how migrants choose to spend the money that they receive. This will be achieved in two ways. First, we will use the variation in economic prospects already induced by the treatment in the on-going field experiment to measure whether migrants whose family members have received capital transfers are less likely to remit this additional income to their family in the village. In a second randomized intervention, we will also induce exogenous variation in the migrant’s knowledge about the family’s short-term economic prospects by randomly selecting some migrants to receive information about expected agricultural conditions in their home area. This information will come from the midline survey conducted by IPA and IFPRI. Migrants will be given information about agricultural production in their family member’s area relative to the whole sample. The information will not be specific to the family member so as not to breach confidentiality.
Experimental design
Participants are contacted for a short phone survey to establish contact shortly following collection of their phone number. They will then be called back and invited to an event that is located relatively near to their home. Prior to the event, possible participants are randomized into treatment for two separate interventions:
1. Earned vs unearned income
2. Information treatment and remittances
At the event, those in the earned income group will perform a clerical task and complete a baseline survey over the course of the day. Those in the unearned income group will only complete the baseline survey. At the end of the day, each participant will be paid and offered the opportunity to remit a portion of their payment home to their family member. Those in the information treatment group will be given information regarding whether the economic performance of the farmer club of their family member in the previous season before making the decision whether to remit.
Following the event, all participants will be targeted with a weekly phone survey for one month that records information on expenditures, labor supply, and remittances.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.