Opting For A Preferential Tax Regime – The Role Of Accountants And Long Term Incentives On Small Businesses’ Behaviour

How to cite

Svraka, András; Keresztély, Tibor; Horváth, Katalin. 2021. "Opting For A Preferential Tax Regime – The Role Of Accountants And Long Term Incentives On Small Businesses’ Behaviour." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0007259. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7259-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

András Svraka* , Tibor Keresztély , Katalin Horváth

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0007259
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7259-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2020-12-04 – 2021-01-31
Countries
Hungary ()
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/7259

Abstract

Hungarian small businesses have access to a preferential small business tax regime (SBT). SBT offers show term benefits with lower tax rates and easier administration relative to the general corporate tax regime. Additionally it has long term benefits through its cash-flow design, favouring firms who invest their profits. Despite their eligibility and potential gains, many firms do not opt for SBT. Previous trials showed that the tax authority can increase take-up rate by directly providing information on SBT to eligible firms. In this randomized field experiment we investigate two questions. Is targeting this messaging to firms, or their accountants effective; and is emphasizing long term benefits over short term benefits more effective. The results will shed light on small businesses' decision-making.

Intervention

The trial consisted of two subtrials with similar interventions but different experimental design. We sent informational letters on the benefits of SBT to the recipients official eGovernment inboxes. The first subtrial aimed at the accountants’ role on firms choices. Here, in one treatment arm firms received the informational letter, and in the other arm their registered accountant received the letter. The second subtrial aimed at the effects of short, or long term benefits on firms’ behaviour. In the first arm letters emphasized immediate gains (lower taxes and easier administration), in the second letters emphasized long term benefits (profits are not taxed until paid out as dividend, raising capital is not taxed).

Experimental design

In the first subtrial we used a block-clustered design. As firms can share accountants, treatments had to be assigned based on accountant clusters, and therefore randomization was also done at accountant level. Blocks were generated based on cluster size (number of eligible firms in the target population of the current trial, who share the same accountant); the share of firms already in SBT and among an accountant’s clients in the current target population (SBT firms did not receive any treatment, they were only used in the construction of clusters); a measure of the intensity of communication to the accountant’s clients in previous SBT related informational campaigns; and a proxy measure of the size of the accountancy based on its VAT filing status.

The second subtrial was a block randomized design, with blocks based on the number of SBT related informational letters received in previous years and the amount of estimated immediate absolute tax gains when choosing SBT. The target population of the second subtrial
does not have an overlap with the population of the first subtrial through common accountants.

Design details

Randomization method
Computer (randomizr package in R)
Randomization unit
Clusters of firms who share an accountant (1st subtrial), firms (2nd subtrial)
Clusters
10,478 in the first subtrial, not available in the second subtrial
Observations
52,631 firms (30,201 in the first, 22,430 in the second subtrial)
Arms
First subtrial: in 5,237 clusters 15,217 firms were treated, and in 5,237 clusters accountants were treated. Second subtrial: 11,215 firms in both treatment arms (short term, long term)
Primary outcomes
Switching to the preferential SBT tax regime by early 2021 at the firm level
Partners
Name: National Tax and Customs Administration of Hungary Partner_type: government Url: https://en.nav.gov.hu/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords