Unemployment and Employability: Intervention to Study Effectiveness of Online Job Information on Job Search in Saudi Arabia

How to cite

Hanna, Rema; Abel, Martin; Pande, Rohini. 2021. "Unemployment and Employability: Intervention to Study Effectiveness of Online Job Information on Job Search in Saudi Arabia." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0007258. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7258-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Rema Hanna* , Martin Abel , Rohini Pande

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0007258
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7258-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2017-03-08 – 2022-12-15
Countries
Private
JEL codes
I38; J16, J64, J65, 012
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/7258

Abstract

This study evaluates the effect of Saudi Arabia’s unemployment insurance (UI) program (Hafiz) on labor market outcomes. We first use administrative data to analyze how behavior changes before and after the 12-month unemployment insurance. To better understand the effect of providing information to Hafiz beneficiaries, we then implement three experiments. The first experiment, (1) Q5 Employment Bonus, presents treated individuals with information about the Qarar 5 (Q5) employment bonus program. The Q5 program was designed to reward early exist from Hafiz, by structuring employment bonus amounts to increase with the number of remaining UI payments. The second experiment, (2) Employment Trends, first asks respondents to estimate the share of women in different economic sectors of the country and then presents the actual percentage. Finally, the third experiment, (3) Employer Demand for Women, asks respondents to estimate the share of women that receive interview requests from certain employment sectors, and then presents the actual shares.

Intervention

To better understand the effect of providing information to Hafiz beneficiaries, we implement three experiments. The first experiment, (1) Q5 Employment Bonus, presents treated individuals with information about the Qarar 5 (Q5) employment bonus program. The Q5 program was designed to reward early exist from Hafiz, by structuring employment bonus amounts to increase with the number of remaining UI payments. The second experiment, (2) Employment Trends, first asks respondents to estimate the share of women in different economic sectors of the country and then presents the actual percentage. Finally, the third experiment, (3) Employer Demand for Women, asks respondents to estimate the share of women that receive interview requests from certain employment sectors, and then presents the actual shares.

Experimental design

We evaluate the effects of information provision through three experiments:

(1) Information on the Q5 Employment Bonus: The Q5 reemployment incentive program was launched in 2014 to incentivize Hafiz beneficiaries to seek employment opportunities before exhausting the total duration of unemployment benefits. The program was designed to reward early exit from Hafiz by providing an “employment bonus” payment to Hafiz beneficiaries that become employed and exit the program before the maximum duration of assistance. The amount of the bonus is structured as a fraction of the remaining unemployment assistance payments. Beneficiaries in the randomly assigned treatment group were presented with information on the Q5 employment bonus program. Then immediate results were collected for both the control and treatment groups; beneficiaries were asked if they were interested in being contacted by a Job Placement Center and if they were interested in searching for jobs on the NLG.

(2) Female Employment Trends: Beneficiaries were presented the share of women in 2010 in each of four different sectors—retail, education, financial services, and construction—and asked to estimate the share of women in 2015. Beneficiaries in the randomly assigned treatment group were shown the actual percentage of women in each sector in 2015 and asked to rate the importance of various barriers on female participation in the labor market. Then immediate results were collected for both the control and treatment groups; beneficiaries were asked if they were interested in being contacted by a Job Placement Center and if they were interested in searching for jobs on the NLG.

(3) Employer Demand for Female Workers: Beneficiaries were asked to estimate the percentage of women that received interview requests from employers in four different sectors: retail, education, financial services, and construction. Beneficiaries in the randomly assigned treatment group were shown the actual percentage of women that received interview requests. Then immediate results were collected for both the control and treatment groups; beneficiaries were asked if they were interested in being contacted by a Job Placement Center and if they were interested in searching for jobs on the NLG.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization was performed by the research team prior to the experiment. Out of the total sample, 2/3 went to the treatment group and 1/3 to control.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
NA
Observations
152,414 beneficiaries: (1) Q5 Employment Bonus: 60,921 beneficiaries (2) Employment Trends: 45,158 beneficiaries (3) Employer Demand for Women: 46,335 beneficiaries
Arms
NA
Primary outcomes
1) Interest in being contacted by Job Placement Center or the National Labor Gateway (NLG) 2) Number of job applications and whether the individual submitted an application through the NLG system applied dummy through NLG system 3) Employment outcomes
Secondary outcomes
Information on job search channels and understanding of labor market in Saudi Arabia

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords