Gender Differences in Negotiation Behavior and the Role of Information

How to cite

Yükselen, Ipek; Bassetto, Jacopo. 2021. "Gender Differences in Negotiation Behavior and the Role of Information." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0007257. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7257-1.2

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Ipek Yükselen* , Jacopo Bassetto

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0007257
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7257-1.2
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2020-12-11 – 2022-12-01
Countries
Germany ()
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/7257

Abstract

Previous studies show a gender difference in wage negotiation behavior which may explain part of the gender wage gap. However, how to close this negotiation gap and its link to the gender wage gap remains unclear. This project aims to produce causal evidence on the means to encourage negotiation behavior among graduates (particularly female graduates), i.e., which instruments are effective to incentivize women to negotiate more, and whether increasing negotiation reduces the gender wage gap. I will randomly assign German master students into an information treatment, a role model treatment and a control group. I will also cross-randomize all groups with a negotiation training invitation. The information treatment includes information on gender differences in negotiation and wages while the role model treatment contains personalized information on negotiation experiences conveyed by successful role models. The negotiation training treatment includes five negotiation training videos prepared by an expert in this field.

I will implement an online randomized field experiment with master students before graduation and use an online survey to follow them at labor market entry after graduation. In addition to the follow-up survey, linking the collected data with the register employment data from the Institute for Employment Research (IAB) will allow me to observe the realized gender wage gap among the graduates, as well as additional employment and firm characteristics. With the questionnaire implemented in the first wave of the field experiment, I aim to ask detailed questions on negotiation behavior, salary and job search expectations, and personality traits. The follow-up survey in the second wave will reveal which treatment has the strongest impact on the negotiation behavior of women in a first job interview after graduation, and consequently, on decreasing the gender wage gap. Furthermore, the administrative data of the linked dataset will allow me to observe the long-run effects of negotiation on the labor market outcomes of graduates.

Intervention

This research project will recruit final-year master students from around 400 universities in Germany. The recruited students will be randomly assigned to a control group or one of 5 treatment groups. The information treatment group will be provided with information on the association between gender differences in negotiation and wages, the role-model treatment group will receive personalized information on negotiation experiences conveyed by successful role models and the negotiation training treatment involves negotiation training videos offered to the participants to watch. The information and negotiation training group includes both the information treatment and the negotiation training treatment. The last treatment group, the role-model and negotiation training group will receive the role-model treatment and the negotiation training.

Experimental design

1. Sampling Method

A survey link will be sent to approximately 400 German universities with a request to distribute the link to their master student e-mail lists. In addition, the survey will be advertised in student newspapers and on social media in order to achieve a maximum number of participants

2. Experimental Design

The master students will be stratified by their field of study (5 categories), gender, grades (3 categories) and graduation date (2 categories) and randomly assigned to one of the 6 groups (1 control, 5 treatment groups) as soon as participants join the survey. After answering some pre-treatment questions, the students in the treatment groups will receive the information or role model treatments, as described below. The negotiation training will be randomly offered to half of all participants. The negotiation training treatment includes five 5-15 minutes long negotiation training videos prepared by an expert in this field. The negotiation training will be cross-randomized with the three groups:

1. Information Treatment: Master students assigned to the information treatment will receive statistics on the gender negotiation gap and on women’s income losses relative to men due to a lower propensity to negotiate.

2. Role Model Treatment: Several women and one man provide examples of their negotiation experiences and some negotiation advice to the master students.

3. Control group: Students assigned to this group will not receive the information or role model treatment.

Therefore, the students will be randomly assigned to one of the 6 groups:

1. Control
2. Control, negotiation training
3. Information
4. Information, negotiation training
5. Role-Model
6. Role-Model, negotiation training

In addition, the survey participants are asked for their consent to link their survey data with administrative data on their labor market history.

Design details

Randomization method
Stratified Randomization will be done in an online survey portal called “keyingress”.
Randomization unit
The master students will be stratified by their field of study (5 categories), gender, grades (3 categories) and graduation date (2 categories).
Clusters
Not applicable.
Observations
The target sample size is approximately 6,000 final-year master students.
Arms
1000 observations per treatment arm.
Primary outcomes
Short Term Realized negotiation behavior, realized negotiation outcomes, entry wages, wage differences as a result of negotiation. Long Term Wages
Secondary outcomes
The survey instrument has been designed to collect data on multiple secondary outcomes, including own future plans of negotiating, expected negotiation outcomes, wage expectations, negotiation-related beliefs, reservation wage and initial wage demand. Finally, the survey includes questions on the number of job applications and main job-search channels.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords