Contact in the Workplace and Social Cohesion: Experimental Evidence from Uganda
How to cite
Silva-Vargas, Mariajose; Loiacono, Francesco. 2021. "Contact in the Workplace and Social Cohesion: Experimental Evidence from Uganda." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0007238. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7238-2.3
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Social cohesion is a driver of trust among members of the same community and, consequently, it is key to local economic development. A high influx of outsiders, such as refugees, might disrupt this cohesion, as the arrival of foreigners may change social relations. Therefore, how to construct social cohesion in refugee-host countries is both desirable and necessary for policy. We conduct a randomized control trial with refugee job seekers and native workers in locally owned and managed firms in Uganda. We measure social cohesion through a compound measure incorporating attitudes, implicit and explicit biases, and behaviors in real and hypothetical activities. Does intergroup contact in the workplace promote social cohesion between people from two different communities? Our sets of findings are two. First, explicit bias decreases for both groups, while implicit bias increases only for native workers. Second, both groups of workers improve their behaviors towards the opposite group, but in a slightly different way: While local workers want to have more refugee business partners, refugee workers want to be more employed by Ugandan firms. These findings underscore the role of workplace-based contact in developing social cohesion by reducing explicit biases and increasing positive behaviors among people from different communities.
Intervention
Our main treatment is work contact which includes direct and indirect contact at the workplace. The different interventions are as follows:
Direct contact: In order to promote direct contact, we run a job placement program that assists displaced populations in finding jobs in Uganda. The program provided a one-week internship to skilled refugees in Ugandan firms that were willing to participate. In order to match refugees with firms, we first tested refugees' skills. The test is an official exam run by the Directorate of Industrial Training, the agency established by the Ministry of Education to be in charge of the vocational education curriculum in Uganda. We also had the support of two large refugee-led NGOs based in Kampala to organize the skills testing. Refugees who passed the test were randomly matched to firms in the same sector as the refugees' occupation. We offered a small subsidy to refugees for the internship that was substantial and equal to about 85% of the monthly median earnings of the refugees. Half of the subsidy was paid upon beginning the internship, the other half upon completing it. The internship lasted one week. Local workers are employees of the firm.
Indirect contact: The indirect contact took place through a video documentary that we shot in Kampala in March 2021. The video is a short 4-minute documentary about relatable and real-life characters from both groups: Elvis Zani, a Ugandan worker from Kampala -- to relate to local workers -- and Paul Kithima, an urban refugee worker in Kampala. We avoid mentioning the nationality of the refugee worker to make the character relatable to all refugees belonging to any nationality. Both workers work together in permaculture. We chose this specific case as we wanted the characters to work in a sector that does not belong to the direct contact treatment, in order to avoid any priming effect.
In the video, both characters talk about their experience working together, what they learned from each other, and what they think about refugees and Ugandans collaborating on the workplace. The video also has a musical background without lyrics that was piloted and it is relatable to all nationalities. Moreover, the video is in English with subtitles in 6 languages (the languages spoken by our respondents) and respondents could decide in which language they wanted the subtitles to be in. The video was piloted with both groups in June 2021 in order to make sure the main message was transmitted, and no other factors were seen as major points.
Experimental design
For the analysis, we consider 1 treatment group, which comprises respondents that randomly received direct contact, indirect contact, or both. The control group is composed of refugee workers that are not matched to any firm and local workers that are not matched to work together with refugees, and workers that watch the placebo video.
Design details
Papers from this trial
- Silva-Vargas, M. & Loiacono, F. 2024. Contact in the Workplace and Social Cohesion: Experimental Evidence from Uganda https://files.cargocollective.com/c419606/SilvaVargas_Loiacono_SocialCohesion.pdf
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.