Testing a condensed methodology to estimate distributional preferences à la Fisman et al. (2007) – Follow-up Study
How to cite
Baader, Malte; Tufano, Fabio; Starmer, Chris; Gächter, Simon. 2021. "Testing a condensed methodology to estimate distributional preferences à la Fisman et al. (2007) – Follow-up Study." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0007217. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7217-2.6
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Estimating individual distributional preferences has become a widely used technique in behavioural economics research. A frequently utilised methodology to do so has been put forward by Fisman, Kariv and Markovits (2007). In their methodology, subjects make distributional choices in 50 modified dictator games, which are then used to estimate two distinct utility parameters. One captures the relative weight for the own payoff (α) and the other describes an efficiency-equity trade off (ρ). In this study, we use the original and new data to explore whether we can reduce the number of distributional choices made by subjects whilst still accurately estimating preference parameters. Simulation results, already obtained by us, show high accuracy in estimating both parameters when using as few as 20 dictator games. In order to experimentally confirm our simulations, we collected a first wave (Wave 1) of data, indicating good performance of our proposed methodology. However, we are going to extend the analysis with additional data to explore some aspects of the results based on Wave 1 data.
Experimental design
Our proposed methodology only utilised 20 modified dictator games, rather than 50 as in Fisman et al. (2007). However, the price ratios of the games are not randomly drawn but the draw follows a bimodal distribution.
In Wave 1 of data collection we compared the original (Fisman et al., 2007) with our proposed methodology across the following three treatments:
1. Control – Original design using 50 modified dictator games.
2. Treatment 20 + 30 – First 20 dictator games according to our proposed methodology, last 30 follow the original design.
3. Treatment 20 & 20 – Two independent sets of our proposed methodology spaced out by a filler task.
If our proposed methodology is as effective as the original one, we should observe comparable distributions of alpha and rho parameters across treatments. From our simulation exercise, we predicted very consistent estimates of alpha and slightly more noisy estimates of rho. Overall, Wave 1 confirmed our predictions that the estimated parameters across the methodologies are identical, except for our estimates of alpha in ‘Treatment 20 + 30’. This seems to be an anomaly, as we also fail to obtain identical distributions of alpha parameters when estimating the parameter based on 50 dictator games, as in the original methodology.
As we collected data for the different treatments in two distinct weekdays, we hypothesise that the inconsistent estimations of alpha are likely to be a result of sampling error and imperfect randomisation.
Thus, in order to address this concern in this follow-up study we want to collect additional data for our ‘Control’ and ‘Treatment 20 + 30’ but with randomisation of subjects to conditions within a session. Through this randomisation strategy, we hope to diagnose the anomalous results from Wave 1.
Reference
Fisman, R., Kariv, S., & Markovits, D. (2007). Individual preferences for giving. American Economic Review, 97(5), 1858-1876.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.