Job search assistance for vocational students
How to cite
Uhlendorff, Arne; Cahuc, Pierre; Hervelin, Jérémy. 2021. "Job search assistance for vocational students." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0007162. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7162-3.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
In France, the unemployment rate of vocational students is high compared to apprentices who get the same diploma. In this project, we evaluate a counseling and job search assistance program for vocational students. The program consists of two parts:
First, the students participate in a general counseling program. This is a group-level treatment which takes place in classes during regular school times. This part of the program complements courses provided by teachers aiming to help students for their professional orientation. These courses contain elements of job search counseling. The overall number of hours of these courses is equal to 91 hours. Caseworkers of the French public employment service (PES) intervene in the class with the teacher for around 25 hours from January to mid-June.
Second, half of the students are followed up and get individual job search assistance with proposals of job offers. This part of the program starts after the graduation of the vocational students and it is a one-to-one treatment. The program is delivered by caseworkers from mid-June to October.
We randomize at three levels. First, we randomly select schools. One group will participate in the program (treated schools), while schools of the other group do not get any treatment (control schools). Second, within the treated schools, we randomize at the class level. The students in the treated classes participate in the group-level counseling program delivered by the caseworkers. Third, for the second part of the program, which occurs after graduation, we randomize at the student level within the treated classes. The caseworker will offer individual job search assistance to the randomly selected students. Together this enables us to analyze (i) the impact of the counseling program delivered by caseworkers of the French PES compared to a standard course of professional orientation provided by teachers, and (ii) the impact of a one-to-one job search assistance program.
Intervention
The intervention consists of two parts. The first part is a counseling program which mainly takes place at the class level, but which also contains some individual sessions. The second part takes place after the end of the school year and is an individual job search assistance program.
Part 1: Counseling program
In this counseling program, in each treated class, caseworkers provide general information about the employment prospects of the students, the students learn about the relevance of specific skills on the labor market, and they apply tools to define and to measure their own skills. Moreover, they learn how to search for a job, how to apply to a job, and how to present themselves in a job interview. The students will also meet employers in their local labor market and visit firms. These collective sessions are combined with individual sessions. In these individual sessions, the students discuss the professional project and their job search with the caseworker. They also have access to a psychologist who advises them in developing their professional project. Overall, this program consists of around 25 hours; around 20 hours for the collective sessions and around 5 hours for the individual sessions. This first treatment takes place from January 2022 to June 2022.
Part 2: Individual job search assistance program
In this part, the treated students get an intensified support with the possibility of mobilizing the services offered by the PES. This includes the proposal of job offers to the students and the recommendation of the students to potential employers. This might also include the placement of internships for the students. In this case, the caseworker would continue supporting the students during the internship in their job search process. The goal of this part of the program is to help the students to find a stable job. This second treatment will take place from mid-June 2022 until October 2022.
The intervention will be repeated in 2023 with the same schools selected for the intervention in 2022 (the treatment status will not change over time) and with additionally selected schools.
The intervention will be repeated in 2024 with the same schools selected for the intervention in 2023. The treatment status of the schools will not change over time. In contrast to the previous years, in 2024 all classes of treated schools will be treated.
Experimental design
We set up the experiment in 8 regions in France. In these regions, we have around 400 public vocational schools entering our experiment. The group of treated schools will consist of about 200 schools. The treatment in the schools will be delivered by around 50 counsellors employed by the public employment service (Pôle Emploi). Each of these 50 counsellors will be in charge of 4 schools.
Our starting points for the randomization are the local offices of the public employment service in the participating regions. For each local office, we identify the vocational schools which are reachable within less than 60 minutes by car. We select those local offices which have a sufficiently large number of vocational schools in their area (usually those with at least 8 vocational schools reachable within less than 60 minutes by car since each agency is in charge of 4 schools). For each of these schools, we observe the average share of students which have been employed 6 months after finishing the school in the years 2018 and 2019. Within schools we additionally observe this employment rate at the class level. Each class corresponds to one specific occupational degree.
In a first step, we randomly select schools to participate in the experiment. For this, we stratify schools by average employment rates of the graduates of previous cohorts. This stratification takes place within the schools which are allocated to the same public employment office.
In a second step, we randomly choose within each school half of the classes to participate in the experiment. For this, we stratify the classes by the employment rates observed for graduates who have chosen the same occupational track in the same school in previous years. Students in the selected classes will be offered to participate in the counseling program (part 1 of the intervention).
In a third step, we randomly choose half of the students who participate in the first part of the intervention. The selected students will be contacted by the counsellor of the public employment service and they will be offered to participate in an individual job search assistance program (part 2 of the intervention).
Students choose during the final year whether they want to prepare themselves for entering the labor market (professional track) or whether they want to go on with their studies (higher education track). Our intervention is designed for the first group of students (professional track). If possible, we will collect pre- and post-treatment information about the type of track the students have chosen.
We can distinguish four groups of students. First, we observe outcomes for students who are in the professional track in non-treated schools (group A). Second, we observe outcomes of students in the professional track in non-treated classes (group B) within treated schools. Third, we observe outcomes of students who participate in the group-level treatment and who were not assigned to the individual job counseling program (group C). Fourth, we observe outcomes of students who get the group-level treatment and who are offered the individual counseling program (group D).
Our design allows us to analyze different effects of the interventions:
(1) A comparison of groups D and C will allow us to estimate the additional effect of the individual counseling program compared to the group level program only.
(2) A comparison of groups D and B will give us an estimate of the joint effect of the group level treatment and the individual counseling program.
(3) A comparison of groups D and A will give us an estimate of the joint effect of the group level treatment and the individual counseling program without potential displacement and spillover effects within schools.
(4) A comparison of groups C and B will give us an estimate of the impact of the group level treatment on the outcomes.
(5) A comparison of groups C and A will give us an estimate of the impact of the group level treatment on the outcomes without potential displacement and spillover effects within schools.
(6) A comparison of groups A and B will give us insights about potential displacement effects of the treatment.
The feasibility of the comparisons (2) to (6) will depend on the availability of information about the type of track the students have chosen before the intervention has started (professional or higher education track). In case this information is not available, the corresponding comparisons will be based on all students (professional and higher education track).
We will additionally explore whether the displacement effects differ depending on whether the students in the non-treated schools are outside the labor pools of the labor agencies involved in the experiment. For this, we will divide the group A in two subgroups: Group A1 consists of students in non-treated schools outside the labor pools of labor agencies involved in the experiment, and group A2 consists of students in non-treated schools which are within the labor pools of labor agencies participating in the experiment. We will compare groups A1 and A2 with students in group B.
In 2023, we will repeat the experiment with the schools which have participated in 2022 and we will additionally include new schools. This will lead to around 650 public vocational schools entering our experiment in 2023. The group of treated schools will consist of about 325 schools. The treatment status of schools which already participated in 2022 will not change. The treatment in the schools in 2023 will be delivered by around 90 counsellors employed by the public employment service (Pôle Emploi).
The intervention will be repeated in 2024 with the same schools selected for the intervention in 2023. The treatment status of the schools will not change over time. In contrast to the previous years, in 2024 all classes of treated schools will be treated.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.