A Cluster Randomized Controlled Trial of Blight Remediation and Community Outreach to Improve Residents’ Perceptions of Safety and Wellbeing in Buffalo, NY
How to cite
Robb, Katharine; Creighton, Jessica; Dickens, Eleanor. 2021. "A Cluster Randomized Controlled Trial of Blight Remediation and Community Outreach to Improve Residents’ Perceptions of Safety and Wellbeing in Buffalo, NY." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0007155. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7155-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Blight and crime are detrimental to the physical, mental, and social health of individuals and communities. Blight (e.g. physical disorder, vacant structures) gives the impression of low levels of social cohesion and provides concealed spaces in which criminal activity has been shown to occur. There is growing evidence that place-based interventions may successful and sustainable in improving wellbeing by changing the structures of places that enable crime and blight to remain persistently high. This place-based intervention brings together public servants and community partners for intensive and rapid beautification and restoration, outreach and education, and codes and law enforcement focused on blocks in distressed neighborhoods. The program runs May-October, targeting clusters of 200 properties each week. The goal is to eliminate blight and foster block-level community connections in order to improve residents’ wellbeing. However, there has been no prior research on the causal impact of the initiative. In this study, we will conduct a cluster randomized controlled trial to evaluate the impact of blight remediation and community outreach, as delivered through the intervention, on residents’ wellbeing. Wellbeing measured through a panel survey. This study will produce evidence regarding the impact of city-led, place-based initiatives to tackle blight, reduce crime, and improve wellbeing.
Research Questions:
Primary:
1. Does the Clean Sweep Initiative improve residents’ [perception of] wellbeing?
Secondary:
2. Does the Clean Sweep Initiative reduce crime?
3. Does reduction in visible blight sustain after six months?
4. Does the Clean Sweep Initiative change social perception of neighborhood activities/characteristics?
Intervention
The intervention targets approximately 200 properties within a 2-3 block area, and occur each Wednesday between May and October for 4.5 hours (8:30am to 1pm). Approximately 32 interventions occur per year and each involves 50-70 community partners and city employees. Activities typically include: boarding up abandoned structures, removing graffiti and debris, code enforcement (mostly related to exteriors of homes), community policing (police peacemakers making introductions with residents), trimming trees, repairing signs, and going door-to-door offering governmental, employment and health & human services information [1]. Issues that cannot be addressed at the time of the intervention (less than 10% of issues) are typically addressed within 24 hours.
Implementation of the intervention is rolled out with the same or similar city and community partners each week. However, the type of work that is done depends on the needs in a given area (e.g. graffiti removal teams only carry out work in blocks with graffiti). If there are known problem properties in a block, code enforcement officers may plan to enter the home and conduct an inspection. However, most of code enforcement work is related to the exterior of homes, unless inspectors are invited in.
Experimental design
A data-driven selection process will be used to generate the sampling frame of eligible clusters. All census block groups (CBGs) in the city will be assigned a “priority score”. The scores will be based on a combination of factors including: building permits, police incidents, property sales, current use (commercial, vacant, residential, recreation, natural areas, community services, industrial, other), low-income population (percent at the census block level), unemployment rate (percent at the census block level), and housing cost burden (percent at the census block level). Additionally, each property in the city will be assigned a priority score based on a combination of factors including: 311 calls, police incidents, building permits, code violation, condition of property, fix and flip, property sales, and property tax delinquency status. These scores will be used to determine where clusters should be located within priority CBGs. CBGs with a score of over 55 and properties with an eligibility score of over 40 will be eligible to receive the intervention.
Final generation of the sampling frame will take place within BuildingBlocks, wherein the researchers will eliminate any non-qualifying CBGs, which include a large proportion of properties that are not eligible (i.e. cemeteries, parks, large commercial districts, etc.). Within the priority areas, primarily contained within one CBG, clusters of 200 properties will be selected as eligible. Most clusters will be contained to one council district and one CBG, however based on neighborhood layout, there will be a few exceptions. Where this is the case, in the analysis we will use a weighted average of CBG characteristics for each cluster, proportional to the number of properties from each CBG. The City of Buffalo will visit eligible locations to assess suitability to provide final certification for inclusion in the sampling frame.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.