Improving Compliance to Iron and Folic Acid Supplementation Protocols: Experimental Evidence from Rural India

How to cite

Patel, Tirtha; Radhakrishnan, Diksha; Barnhardt, Sharon; Mamidi, Pavan. 2021. "Improving Compliance to Iron and Folic Acid Supplementation Protocols: Experimental Evidence from Rural India." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0007143. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7143-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Tirtha Patel* , Diksha Radhakrishnan , Sharon Barnhardt , Pavan Mamidi

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0007143
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7143-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2020-10-22 – 2021-01-22
Countries
India (Uttar Pradesh)
JEL codes
I12
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/7143

Abstract

In this randomised controlled trial study, we will evaluate the impact of three communication-based interventions, delivered remotely, on improving the consumption of Iron and Folic Acid (IFA) supplements during pregnancy in rural India. Our interventions aim to make the risks of anemia for both mother and child salient, increase the value perception of IFA supplements amongst pregnant women, and support the habit formation of their daily consumption. We test for these interventions using two experiments; in the first, we randomize pregnant women with access to Whatsapp between control and a treatment, where the treatment group is given simplified counselling over the phone followed by some visual reinforcements over Whatsapp; in our second, we randomize pregnant women without access to Whatsapp between control and two treatments, where one treatment group is given simplified counselling over the phone followed by regular prescriptions of IFA tablets sent through SMS, and the second treatment group is sent catchy and tuneful IVRS reminders for regular tablet consumption. We deploy our experiments in rural Uttar Pradesh, with a sample of 1929 pregnant women.

Intervention

We have three interventions that we test in our two separate experiments:

(1) IVRS Reminders:
(a) Series of 13 behaviorally designed reminders using insights to grab attention and increase recall
(b) They were meant to invoke joy, humor, and excitement about the new baby while reminding individuals to consume IFA tablets daily for ensuring the baby’s health
(c) Delivered daily for the first 7 days and then every 2 days for the next 3 weeks

(2) Phone Counselling + SMS Prescription:
(a) Pregnant women were called on the phone (early morning or at night) and counseled on IFA and anemia
(b) The tone of the counseling was joyful and conveyed respect
(c) Script highlighted the risk of anemia
(d) Delivered 1 day after the pregnant women received phone counseling
(e) A prescription for IFA tablets with standard government-recommended dosage, along with instructions for avoiding side effects was sent to select pregnant women
(f) Personalized with the woman’s name and sent once every week for 4 weeks

(3) Phone Counselling + Whatsapp Visual Reinforcement
(a) Pregnant women were called on the phone (early morning or at night) and counseled on IFA and anemia
(b) The tone of the counseling was joyful and conveyed respect
(c) Script highlighted the risk of anemia
(d) Delivered 1 day after the pregnant women received phone counseling
(e) Smartphone users in this arm received visual information about risks to repeat the key framing
(f) Sent once every week for 4 weeks

Experimental design

Our research design is a straightforward randomised controlled field trial, where pregnant women between 4th to 8th month of the pregnancy are eligible for either the Feature Phone based experiment or the Smart Phone based experiment -- depending on whether they have access to WhatsApp.
1. Experiment 1a (Feature Phone Experiment): Participants were randomised between Control group, IVRS Reminders Treatment and Phone Counselling + SMS Prescription Treatment
2. Experiment 1b (Smart Phone Experiment): Participants were randomised between Control group, and Phone Counselling + Whatsapp Visual Reinforcement Treatment

Our treatments are bookended by a baseline and an endline, where we measure IFA tablet consumption and adherence practices, attitudes and intentions, along with standard demographics.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization was performed using the computational software R.
Randomization unit
We conducted stratified randomization at an individual level for both the experiments.
Clusters
Clustering is not applicable to either of the two experiments.
Observations
Experiment 1a: 1477 pregnant women Experiment 1b: 646 pregnant women
Arms
Experiment 1a: Control: 492 pregnant women IVRS Reminders: 492 pregnant women Phone Counselling + SMS Prescription: 493 pregnant women Experiment 1b: Control: 324 pregnant women Phone Counselling + Whatsapp Visual Reinforcement: 322 pregnant women
Primary outcomes
Our primary outcome variables are practice-related outcomes: 1. Total Consumption - total number of IFA tablets consumed 2. Adherence to Total Consumption - rate of regular consumption at Endline and rate of regular consumption between Baseline and Endline 3. Daily Consumption in the previous week - average number of tablets consumed in a day in the previous week 4. Adherence in the previous week - rate of regular consumption over a week
Secondary outcomes
Our secondary outcome variables are: 1. Knowledge-related variables: Awareness about Anemia, Knowledge about Anemia's symptoms and risks and Knowledge about IFA tablets' side effects 2. Attitude-related variables: Risk perception of Anemia, Threat perception of IFA tablet non-consumption (to mother and child), Intention to consumption, Self-Efficacy, Value perception of IFA tablets

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords