Effects of Supportive Leadership Behaviors on Worker Satisfaction, Engagement and Performance: An Experimental Field Investigation

How to cite

Haeckl, Simone; Rege, Mari. 2021. "Effects of Supportive Leadership Behaviors on Worker Satisfaction, Engagement and Performance: An Experimental Field Investigation." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0007129. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7129-1.2000000000000002

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Simone Haeckl* , Mari Rege

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0007129
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7129-1.2000000000000002
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2021-04-04 – 2023-12-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/7129

Abstract

Research demonstrates that leaders vary extensively in their capabilities to scaffold human potential. Still, we have limited understanding of how different leadership behaviors cause workers to be engaged and motivated to work hard and smart. We conduct a field experiment in a large corporation to investigate effects of supportive leadership behaviors on worker satisfaction, engagement and performance. The CEO encourages all employees to participate in group discussions to provide input on a question of strategic importance during work hours. The employees with no personnel responsibility are randomly matched to employees with personnel responsibility (leader) to form groups of three or four members, all from different companies within the corporation to maximize the likelihood of them not knowing each other. Using block randomization, the leaders are randomized into treatment and control. Treated leaders receives a brief leadership-training promoting more supportive leadership behaviors. We investigate treatment impact on worker satisfaction, engagement, and performance in the group task.

Intervention

The intervention is a short online leadership-training promoting supportive leadership behaviors. It first discusses why a leader’s behaviors may have an impact on worker’s engagement and performance. Then it describes concrete leadership behaviors that can support engagement and performance. It also prompts the leaders to reflect on other’s and own leadership behaviors.

Experimental design

We conduct a field experiment in a large corporation to investigate effects of supportive leadership behaviors on worker satisfaction, engagement and performance. The CEO encourages all employees to participate in team discussions to provide input on a question of strategic importance. Employees indicate availability in the week of implementation in the baseline survey. The discussions take place on four consecutive workdays. The employees with no personnel responsibility are randomly matched to employees with personnel responsibility (leader) to form groups of three or four members (accounting for availability), all from different companies within the corporation to maximize the likelihood of them not knowing each other. Under the guidance of the leader, each group spends about 30 minutes discussing the question of strategic importance and summarizes their recommendation for the CEO on a power point slide. Using block randomization, the leaders are randomized into treatment and control. Prior to the group discussions all leaders receive a brief guideline on how to guide the discussion using Microsoft Teams. The instructions are identical, but for the treated leaders it also contains a brief leadership-training promoting more supportive leadership behaviors. We investigate treatment impact on work satisfaction, engagement and performance in the group task.

When estimating treatment impacts, we use several model specifications investigating robustness to adding sets of control variables. All models control for blocks. Additional control variables are: leader sex, leader tenure (years working at the company), leader coaching behavior at baseline (Heslin et al., 2006), leader mindset at baseline (Chiu et al., 1997), group size, group member average tenure, group member average creative mindset (Karwowksi, 2014) at baseline.

We investigate differential treatment effects across leader’s sex, leader’s tenure (median split), leader mindset at baseline (measured using the 8-item scale of Chiu et al. (1997), median split), and coaching behavior at baseline (measured using a 6-item instrument developed by Heslin et al. (2006) median split).

Design details

Randomization method
stratified randomization based on the day of the intervention using the randomize command in STATA by Kennedy and Mann.
Randomization unit
leader (work teams)
Clusters
Expected nr. of clusters: 140 leaders
Observations
In addition to the 140 leaders, we plan to have 380 employees, i.e.,2-3 employees per leader, leading to 380 observations on employee level
Arms
clusters will be equally split across treatments: 70 in the control and 70 in the treatment condition
Primary outcomes
Individual level: Employee Engagement (survey measure), Work Satisfaction (survey measure); Group level: Group Engagement (video recording measure), Group Performance (ppt measure), Group Creativity (“Unusual Uses Task”)
Secondary outcomes
Leadership behaviors during group task (survey measure, perceived by group members), Leadership behaviors during group task (video recording measure), Mindset (both of employees and employers)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords