Improving Legal Training: the Impact of Social-Emotional Learning and Class Monitoring on Judicial Performance
How to cite
Maqueda, Manuel Ramos; Silveira, Bernardo; Chen, Daniel. 2021. "Improving Legal Training: the Impact of Social-Emotional Learning and Class Monitoring on Judicial Performance." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0007113. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7113-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Despite the importance of high-stake judicial decisions on litigants' wellbeing and economic development, there is little evidence on how to improve judicial performance. In this paper, we use a randomized controlled trial to evaluate the impact of teacher monitoring and social-emotional exercises on the performance of judges and prosecutors in Peru's Judicial Academy. We test the impact of our interventions on both soft and hard skills that aim to improve not only educational attainment and social-emotional skills, but also contribute to fairer and more efficient judicial decision-making.
Intervention
First, we are implementing an online monitoring program in which classes are observed by a member of the agency’s pedagogical team and teachers receive personalized feedback after each monitored session. Each class in the monitoring group of this intervention is monitored by a member of Judicial Academy's (AMAG's) pedagogical team. The monitor joins the day-long classes for a total of one hour divided into four slots of fifteen minutes spread across the duration of the class. After each class, the teacher meets with the monitor to receive and discuss her feedback during a 30-minute follow-up meeting. Classes in the control group are not monitored and teachers do not receive any feedback.
Second, we are applying online self-reflection exercises to the AMAG's students. Once a month, students will be asked to reflect and write about topics related to the work of judicial professionals. The treatment group will be asked to reflect about their personal experiences whereas the control treatment group will be asked about the same topic but reflecting on others' experience as a judge or prosecutor. These questions will change every month from a list of 9 topics, each of which has a treatment and a control question. To ensure that the writing task is effective, a minimum of words will be required and answers will be peer-reviewed. At the end of the month, students will be asked to rate their peers’ (anonymized) responses to the exercise in terms of how useful they are as advice for future judges and prosecutors. Each student will rate two pairs of responses, selecting their preferred response for each pair.
Experimental design
The research design consists in a randomized controlled trial (RCT) of two main interventions: online monitoring of teachers during classes, and social-emotional learning (SEL) exercises written by the students.
Online monitoring will take place every class (twice a month), and will be randomized at the class level. Those students whose teachers are monitored in the first round will remain in the monitoring group in future courses. The teacher will likely change every month (course), yet the new teacher will also be monitored if the previous teacher was monitored too.
The SEL exercises will take place once a month, when students will be asked to reflect and write about topics related to the work of judicial professionals. At the end of the month, students will review two pairs of anonymized responses from their peers and select their preferred ones from each pair. The SEL topics will not only be randomized across students in each course; the order in which students complete such topics will also be randomized. This will allow us to study the comparative effect of each of these topics, and thus understand which interventions are most helpful to improve educational attainment and professional performance of judges and prosecutors.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.