Discrimination against the mentally ill
How to cite
Ridley, Matthew. 2021. "Discrimination against the mentally ill." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0007100. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7100-6.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
People with depression or anxiety, the most common mental illnesses, often deal with prejudice and unfavorable treatment at work. This could have economic costs if they are discriminated against relative to other equally-productive workers, or treated differently by coworkers in ways that harm productivity. How much does this happen, as opposed to discrimination just reflecting these disorders' direct effects on productivity? This project uses an online experiment to investigate discriminatory behavior towards depressed or anxious coworkers in a collaborative problem-solving task. I estimate discrimination in the preference for working with a person and in in-task behaviors, investigate the mechanisms behind such discrimination and its effects on earnings, and finally consider how this relates to the willingness of participants to reveal information about their mental illness.
Intervention
There are two roles in the experimental task: tourist and guide. The main intervention is whether I reveal a tourist's depression or anxiety symptoms to the guide, when the tourist in fact has these symptoms). Additional, I randomize whether I reveal that a tourist lacks these symptoms, when they do not in fact have them.
A secondary intervention is whether, when choosing roles in the task, participants are told (truthfully) that information on these same symptoms might be revealed to their coworker if they choose one of the roles.
I also randomize what other demographic information alongside mental health is revealed. Guides and tourists are also matched on a first-come first-serve basis as they enter the study, so this is quasi-random in that sense.
Experimental design
My experiment revolves around an online, collaborative navigation task. Players on Amazon’s Mechanical Turk (MTurk) complete the task of guiding a tourist to a destination. They do four rounds of the navigation task divided into two batches of two rounds. In every round, guides see information about the tourist, with the key experimental treatment being whether this includes mental health. I measure this information in a baseline survey.
I elicit guides' willingness to pay to work with specific tourists before and after working with them and investigate how signals of mental health affect this demand. I also estimate how showing tourist mental health information to the guide, conditional on the tourist's actual mental health status, affects the guide's behavior in the task and ultimate earnings in the task.
I also elicit willingness to pay to hide or reveal signals of mental health to potential guides, alongside willingness to pay to reveal other information. This is done in between the first and second batch of two rounds.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.