Government employee and beneficiary preferences about redistribution

How to cite

Olken, Benjamin; Gaduh, Arya; Hanna, Rema. 2021. "Government employee and beneficiary preferences about redistribution." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0007010. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7010-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Benjamin Olken* , Arya Gaduh , Rema Hanna

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0007010
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7010-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2020-09-28 – 2024-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
H53 Government Expenditures and Welfare Programs; I38 Government Policy • Provision and Effects of Welfare Programs; O12 Microeconomic Analyses of Economic Development; C83 Survey Methods • Sampling Methods; A13 Relation of Economics to Social Values
Secondary IDs
IGI-1461
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/7010

Abstract

This study is a survey experiment among conditional cash transfer program facilitators and beneficiaries in Indonesia to gauge how attitudes towards social protection programs are influenced by programmatic factors and how opinions on how rigidly the conditionality of cash transfers should be enforced may be affected by considering the enforcement of conditionality in one’s own community. This study is embedded in a larger survey of beneficiaries and facilitators of Indonesia’s PKH conditional cash transfer program which gathers information on the impact of the COVID-19 crisis on Indonesia’s poorest households and communities. PKH is one of Indonesia’s principal social protection programs, serving 10 million of Indonesia’s poorest, nation-wide. We send online surveys to all PKH facilitators (approximately 36,000 facilitators) via WhatsApp and SMS and use dynamic random sampling to each facilitator to distribute surveys to up to 5 randomly selected beneficiaries.

Intervention

This survey experiment contains two randomized questions:
1) We randomly present respondents with one of seven hypothetical social protection programs with different budget usage and beneficiary satisfaction characteristics and then ask them to assess program success.
2) We randomly ask respondents to consider the tradeoff between rigidity and leniency in the enforcement of cash transfer conditionality, either before or after asking about the enforcement of conditionality in their communities.

Experimental design

This study is embedded in a larger survey of beneficiaries and facilitators of Indonesia’s PKH conditional cash transfer program which gathers information on the impact of the COVID-19 crisis on Indonesia’s poorest households and communities. We send online surveys to all PKH facilitators (approximately 36,000 facilitators) via WhatsApp and SMS and use dynamic random sampling to each facilitator to distribute surveys to up to 5 randomly selected beneficiaries. Each survey contains two experimental questions:
1) Each respondent is asked to evaluate the success of one hypothetical social program characterized by a set of quantifiable program characteristics. This hypothetical scenario is randomized such that each respondent receives only one of seven possible versions. Respondents are then asked to assess the success of the program. The levels of each program characteristics in each of the seven scenarios are designed to facilitate an analysis of how these characteristics influence perceptions of program success.
2) Each respondent is asked to consider the tradeoff between rigidity and leniency in the enforcement of cash transfer conditionality. This question is asked either randomly before or after asking how many beneficiaries in the respondent’s community have had conditional cash transfer payments reduced or suspended in the last 2 years due to failure to meet conditionality requirements.

Design details

Randomization method
Participant selection: For the facilitators, we send out the survey to all facilitators on the official program roster. Beneficiaries are randomly sampled using a dynamic algorithm within the facilitator survey which randomly selects up to 5 beneficiaries per facilitator, among all of a facilitator’s beneficiaries who have smartphones (necessary for completion of the online survey). Question randomization: All experimental questions are randomized automatically by the survey platform.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
N/A
Observations
48,214 individuals: - Facilitators: 28,460 complete responses (95% could be matched to an official facilitator roster) - Beneficiaries: 19,754 complete responses (85% could be matched to an official facilitator survey)
Arms
Sample size by treatment arms for complete responses: 1. Hypothetical social programs A. Facilitators Scenario 1 4.047 Scenario 2 4.069 Scenario 3 4.092 Scenario 4 4.073 Scenario 5 4.073 Scenario 6 4.036 Scenario 7 4.070 B. Beneficiaries Scenario 1 2.830 Scenario 2 2.819 Scenario 3 2.822 Scenario 4 2.801 Scenario 5 2.823 Scenario 6 2.828 Scenario 7 2.831 2. Rigidity vs. leniency conditionality enforcement (asked before or after asking how many beneficiaries in the respondent’s community have had conditional payments reduced or suspended) A. Facilitators Before 14.251 After 14.209 B. Beneficiaries Before 9.858 After 9.896
Primary outcomes
1) Perceived success of the hypothetical social protection program 2) Belief of the extent to which conditionality should be enforced rigidly or leniently
Secondary outcomes
Information on the impact of Covid-19 in Indonesia

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords