Signals We Give: Gender, Feedback, and Competition

How to cite

Coutts, Alexander; Murad, Zahra; Koh, Boon Han. 2021. "Signals We Give: Gender, Feedback, and Competition." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0006966. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6966-3.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Alexander Coutts* , Zahra Murad , Boon Han Koh

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0006966
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6966-3.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2021-02-01 – 2022-12-31
Countries
United States of America ()
JEL codes
C92, D82, J7.
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/6966

Abstract

How do managers convey information to employees about their performance? Are they averse to giving bad news, or are they more likely to withhold good information? This project examines the biases that managers hold when providing feedback to their employees. Biased feedback communication can distort employees’ perceptions about their abilities, which may, in turn, alter their willingness to compete for promotion or roles with better career prospects. Using a series of controlled experiments, we examine biases in feedback provision, and how these interact with the employee’s gender. Understanding these biases and their impact on behavior is an important step to breaking down the barriers inhibiting women from taking up leadership roles. Our experimental design will allow us to examine the relationship between feedback provision and the impact that biased performance feedback may have on employees’ beliefs and behavior.

Experimental design

Participants will be divided into groups of two. One participant is assigned the role of the Manager while the other is assigned the role of the Worker. Managers will receive a signal about their matched Worker’s task performance and choose how they would like to provide feedback to their Worker. The Worker then chooses how they would like to be compensated for their task performance.

NOTE: This project is a follow-up experiment from a previously registered trial (https://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/5543), which was designed as a laboratory experiment. That experiment was abandoned due to the COVID-19 pandemic. In this study, the experiment has been redesigned to be conducted online and to address a revised set of research questions.

Design details

Randomization method
Our experiment follows a 2 × 2 × 2 between-subject treatment design and conducted entirely using participants recruited from Prolific. We will recruit a gender-balanced sample for both Workers and Managers. All treatment assignment is determined randomly using the following protocols: 1. Worker’s gender: Managers will be matched with either a male Worker or a female Worker. This is randomly determined at the individual level by the computer software, such that there are an equal number of male and female Workers to be matched to Managers. 2. Instrumentality of Manager’s feedback (i.e., timing of feedback): Each Manager-Worker pair will be randomly assigned to either the Instrumental treatment or the Non-Instrumental treatment. This will again be randomly determined at the individual level by the computer software, such that there are an equal number of Managers in each treatment. 3. Precision of signal received by Managers: Each Manager will either receive a precise, moderate, or vague signal about their Worker’s performance. This is randomly determined at the individual level using the computer software. The probability distribution of signal types {Precise, Moderate, Vague} is fixed at {0.65, 0.30, 0.05}. Note that managers receiving a vague signal will be excluded from the analysis.
Randomization unit
The unit of randomization is at each Manager-Worker pair level.
Clusters
1,200 (1,200 Workers and 1,200 Managers).
Observations
2,400 (1,200 Workers and 1,200 Managers).
Arms
We plan to recruit 1,200 Managers that will be pre-assigned to one of these four treatment cells: (i) female Workers × instrumental feedback; (ii) female Workers × non-instrumental feedback; (iii) male Workers × instrumental feedback; and (iv) male Workers × non-instrumental feedback. Participants will be recruited via Prolific so that there is a gender-balanced sample of Workers to be matched to Managers. The experiment software will ensure that the Manger-Worker pairs are uniformly assigned to the instrumental and non-instrumental treatments. Hence, within each treatment cell, we expect to have 300 Manager-Worker pairs (i.e., 600 participants). Given the distribution of signal precision, this implies that about 200 Managers within each cell will receive precise signals, while about 100 Managers will receive moderate signals. The probability of receiving a vague signal is negligible, and these observations will be excluded from the analysis.
Primary outcomes
Our primary outcome variables are: 1. Managers’ choice of feedback to be sent to their Worker [FeedbackSent] 2. Worker’s choice of payment scheme [ChoiceTournament]
Secondary outcomes
Our secondary outcome variables are: 1. Manager’s prior and posterior beliefs about the Worker’s performance [BeliefWorkerPrior; BeliefWorkerPosterior] 2. Worker’s prior and posterior beliefs about their own performance [BeliefPrior; BeliefPosterior]

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords