Many paternalistic decisions are made by groups. For example, political parties and government bodies pass laws that restrict the choice sets of citizens, parents restrict the choices of their children and board of directors make decisions that affect the choices of the firm's employees. A small strand of literature has studied why, when and how individuals act paternalistically, but there is no evidence on the paternalistic behavior of groups. However, it is widely acknowledged that groups often behave differently than individuals. Motivated by these considerations, the objective of this study is to investigate paternalism among groups and to study if there are differences in acting paternalistically between individuals and groups. We design a controlled laboratory experiment to study our research questions.
Experimental design
How do Choice Architects make paternalism decisions?
Design details
Randomization method
randomization done in office by a computer
Randomization unit
both within experimental sessions and across experimental sessions (see description of experimental design)
Clusters
610 (at least)
Observations
610 (at least)
Arms
We aim to have at least 100 independent observations in each treatment arm. Because decisions of subjects who are part of a group in stage 2 cannot be treated as independent observations, we have the following number of subjects per treatment arm:
Exogenous Individual: 100
Exogenous Group: 200
Endogenous Individual: 100
Endogenous Group: 200 (or more, depending on how many individuals select to be part of a group)
In addition: collect 10 individual observations about intertemporal and social decisions of Choosers with unrestricted Choice Sets.
In addition: Subjects in the roles of Choosers
Primary outcomes
- Paternalism decision of Choice Architects in Stage 2: no paternalism, soft paternalism, or hard paternalism
- Selection into group: how many subjects and which types of subjects select into groups to make the paternalism decision.
Secondary outcomes
Delegation Decision in stage 4
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.