Attitudes towards science when its’ results (don’t) confirm people’s priors
How to cite
Lergetporer, Philipp; Blesse, Sebastian. 2020. "Attitudes towards science when its’ results (don’t) confirm people’s priors." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0006904. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6904-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The public’s attitudes towards science are crucial for the functioning of enlightened societies, since attitudes towards science may affect support for public funding of scientific activities, policy choices, or the public’s willingness to comply with science-based behavioral rules (e.g., wearing a mask in public during the COVID-19 pandemic).
We hypothesize that public trust in science may depend on the extent to which its findings confirm people’s prior beliefs. To test this hypothesis, we conduct a randomized experiment within a large-scale, representative survey in Germany. Focusing on the controversial question how migration affects natives’ labor-market success, we first elicit all respondents’ beliefs about the impact of migration on natives’ labor-market success. Then, we randomly assign respondents to one of four experimental groups (one control group, three information-treatment groups). Treatment 1 informs that some studies find negative impacts of migration on natives’ labor-market success, treatment 2 informs that some studies find no significant impact, and treatment 3 informs about both types of findings (note that the information provided in all three treatments is truthful). After treatment administration, we measure individuals’ attitudes towards science using several survey questions, and we summarize the answers to these questions into one index, which is our main outcome of interest. In our main analysis, we plan to estimate heterogeneous information-treatment effects by respondents’ prior beliefs. This will allow us to investigate the extent to which scientific findings confirm or contradict people’s priors affects their attitudes towards science. Furthermore, we will estimate treatment effects on individuals’ posterior beliefs about the impact of migration, and on general attitudes towards migration to investigate the extent to which individuals update their beliefs and attitudes about migration in response to (contradicting) scientific information.
Intervention
We investigate how information about scientific findings affects public attitudes towards science. We particularly focus on whether learning about scientific findings that contrast individuals’ prior beliefs lowers individuals’ attitudes towards science. Therefore, we implement an online-survey experiment among a representative sample of adults aged 16 to 75 years in Germany. First, we elicit all respondents’ beliefs about the impact of migration on natives’ labor-market success. Then, we randomly assign respondents into one of four different experimental groups (one control group, three information-treatment groups that all provide truthful information). Treatment 1 informs that some studies find negative impacts of migration on natives’ labor-market success, treatment 2 informs that some studies find no significant impact, and treatment 3 informs about both types of findings. Afterwards, we measure individual’s attitudes towards science in a series of questions that we combine into one index which is our main outcome of interest. Our main analytical focus will be on heterogeneous treatment effects by respondents’ prior beliefs to investigate the extent to which scientific findings confirm or contradict people’s priors affects their attitudes towards science. Furthermore, we will estimate treatment effects on individuals’ posterior beliefs about the impact of migration, and on general attitudes towards migration to investigate the extent to which individuals update their beliefs and attitudes about migration in response to (contradicting) scientific information.
Experimental design
We conduct the experiment in a sample of about 4400 adults aged between 15 and 75 years. The survey is conducted as an online survey within the representative, probability-based “German Internet Panel” (GIP) (see Blom et al., 2015 for details). Our experiment spans over two GIP waves with the same respondents.
Our experiment is structured as follows:
Stage 1: prior beliefs on the impact of migration on natives’ labor-market success (wave 1)
Stage 2: randomized information provision (wave 1)
Control group: No information; Treatment 1: studies find negative impacts of migration on natives’ employment, Treatment 2: studies find no impacts of migration on natives’ employment, Treatment 3: studies find both no and negative impacts of migration on natives’ employment
Stage 3: measuring outcomes
Outcome 1: Credibility of migration studies (wave 1)
Outcome 2: Trust in science (wave 1)
Outcome 3: Demand for more scientific evidence (wave 1)
Re-elicitation of prior beliefs (wave 2)
Re-elicitation of outcome 1 (wave 2)
Reminder about information treatments (wave 2): same treatment assignment as in wave 1
Outcome 4: Demand for evidence-based policy making (wave 2)
Outcome 5: Demand for further information on scientific studies (wave 2)
Outcome 6: Attitudes towards migration (wave 2)
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.