The long-term impact of high-school financial education: Evidence from Spain
How to cite
Machelett, Margarita; Villanueva, Ernesto; Hospido, Laura; Bover, Olympia. 2020. "The long-term impact of high-school financial education: Evidence from Spain." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0006880. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6880-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
In recent decades, many financial education programs have been implemented in schools across many countries. These programs are an effort to increase the persistently low financial literacy levels among the population, and better prepare them for making adult financial decisions. While there is a large literature about the short-run impacts of financial education, (Kaiser, Lusardi, Menkhoff, and Urban 2020) there is less evidence of its impacts in the longer run. That is, when individuals start making more and more financial decisions on a day to day basis, and they make one of the most important financial decisions in their lives: which level of human capital to acquire. We fill this gap by extending Bover, Hospido and Villanueva (2020) causal analysis of a financial education training course implemented in secondary education. The authors find positive short-term effects on financial literacy and an increase in patience in both hypothetical saving choices and in an incentivized saving task. We complement this study by following participants after five years of this program. This allows us to test whether financial education impacts persist over time in financial literacy, but also whether it impacts other outcomes such as financial attitudes, patience, intertemporal decision making, financial inclusion, and earnings and employment expectations. Furthermore, we can study the financial education impact in education choices and provide insights on how those decisions vary with responses to the mentioned outcomes.
Experimental design
This project builds on the educational program that started during the academic year 2012-13, when the plan "Finance for all" was launched by the Banco de EspaƱa and the CNMV to improve financial population among the population. One of the interventions of this program provided basic financial literacy training in Spanish secondary school through an RCT, implemented in 2014-15. This project will study the long-run impacts of this specific intervention, measured by its impacts on financial knowledge, choices, expectations, and educational choices.
As part of the intervention, financial education training was delivered for the first time to students in 9th grade (called Tercero de la ESO in the Spanish schooling system) attending 77 school centers (of the original number of 78 schools participating, one dropped out). The experimental design provided two control groups: the 9th graders receiving financial literacy training later in the school year, and 10th graders (called Cuarto de la ESO in the Spanish schooling system) who did not receive this training but were also surveyed and tested. The current project continues this intervention by surveying participants after five years since financial education training took place. We study its long-run impacts by comparing 9th grader program participants (treated group) to 10th-grade students at the time of the program.
In this project, we survey knowledge in financial literacy, educational choices, labor experience, earning expectations. We also implement an incentivized convex budget set task following Andreoni and Sprenger (2012), Alan and Ertac (2018), Luhrmann, Serra-Garcia, Winter (2018), among others. Given the current pandemic, we also survey each current household situation and public policy assistance receipt.
The survey is implemented through Computer Assisted Telephone and Web Interviewing (CATI and CAWI) by IMOP Insights S.A. IMOP Insights S.A. is the private independent firm that also implemented the financial literacy tests during the academic year 2014-2015.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.