Interactions between fixed and mobile recycling facilities: Do personal norms matter?

How to cite

Trujillo, Francisca; Salazar, César; Jaime, Marcela; Chávez, Carlos. 2020. "Interactions between fixed and mobile recycling facilities: Do personal norms matter?." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0006874. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6874-1.6

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Francisca Trujillo* , César Salazar , Marcela Jaime , Carlos Chávez

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0006874
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6874-1.6
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2020-12-17 – 2022-09-16
Countries
Chile (Osorno)
JEL codes
Q53, D10, C93
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/6874

Abstract

Local governments in middle-income countries have promoted the installation of containers to increase the collection of materials with potential for recycling. However, the level of collected materials is still very low, and concerns on the cleanness of the neighborhood’s surroundings due to misuse of recycling containers have emerged. The objective of this research is to evaluate the impact of a set of alternative policy instruments aimed at encouraging participation in recycling schemes by urban households. In particular, we are interested in studying the effect of the provision of a curbside collection system on the recycling of plastic and waste sorting by households once fixed containers are available. Special attention is given to the interactions between both types of infrastructure. Also, we explore whether appealing to personal norms has a reinforcement effect on the recycling of plastic and waste sorting. The study will be carried out in the city of Osorno, in southern Chile, with the support of the local Municipality, and with the collaboration of the leading recycling company in the city. We will collect information on recycling material two times per week for a set of containers previously installed in two similar sectors, over 18 months. Finally, we will conduct ex-ante and ex-post surveys to gather household-level data in the proximity of the infrastructure. This intervention will provide valuable insights regarding the effects of these instruments on the disposal of plastics in the urban residential setting.

Intervention

This study aims at evaluating the effects of the provision of mobile recycling facilities on plastic recycling and sorting. In addition, we will explore whether the provision of information appealing to personal norms reinforces this later effect. The intervention will consist on the implementation of a mobile recycling service (curbside collection system) once the fixed recycling infrastructure is already in place. Thereby, special attention is given to the interaction between mobile and fixed recycling infrastructure, and the extent to which information with value-laded content plays a role in boosting residential recycling among households.

Experimental design

This project consists of the design and implementation of a randomized field experiment targeting two neighborhoods of Osorno city, in southern Chile. Our intervention is administered in three stages. The first stage considers the implementation of a baseline scenario consisting of the provision of fixed recycling infrastructure/stations in two selected neighborhoods. One of these neighborhoods will be regarded as treatment, and the other as a control. In each neighborhood, there will be one container of mixed materials (i.e., plastics, cardboard, glass) and eight plastic bottle bins, totalizing nine containers per neighborhood and eighteen containers in total. This fixed infrastructure will be installed on the streets of the two neighborhoods, and a specific location of recycling stations will follow a systematic procedure that considers the division of each neighborhood into smaller areas (i.e., polygons). Thus, households will be linked to a particular recycling station through these predetermined zones. The baseline stage will be carried out for six months and, in this period, we will collect information on the amount of recovered plastic waste and the percentage of waste incorrectly sorted, with a temporal frequency of two times per week. In the 6th month, a household survey will be conducted in order to gather households’ characteristics, perceptions, and motivations about recycling, the amount of waste generated in the household, and the use of containers for recycling, among other variables. The second stage considers the implementation of the curbside recycling collection service in the treatment neighborhood, whilst the control neighborhood will remain with only fixed infrastructure. In this phase, there will be mobile and fixed infrastructure at the same time. This phase will take place for another six months so that the first and second stages altogether will be completed in one year. The third stage, starting from month 12, consists of an information campaign targeting households in the treated neighborhood. This intervention consists of the provision of normative information appealing to personal norms. In contrast, households in the control neighborhood will be provided with the same (plane) information they were given in the first and second stages. Finally, an ex-post survey will be carried out at the end of this stage.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer
Randomization unit
Polygons (areas defined by fixed infrastructure)
Clusters
We have 18 polygons (areas defined by fixed infrastructure)
Observations
2808 (1404 in control area and 1404 in treatment area)
Arms
9 polygons in control area and 9 polygons in treatment area
Primary outcomes
(1) Amount of waste recovered for recycling in kilograms per period (units of observation are polygons defined by fixed recycling stations), and (2) Percentage of incorrectly classified material present in the recollected waste (i.e., non-recyclable waste).

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords