Climate and Resilience Impact Evaluation Window: Experimental Evidence from Several Countries

How to cite

Christian, Paul; Kelley, Erin; Holmlund, Marcus; Premand, Patrick; Trako, Iva; Lane, Gregory; Heirman, Jonas; Paulose, Hanna; Fernandez, Chloe; Jospe, Eric; Jeong, Dahyeon. 2020. "Climate and Resilience Impact Evaluation Window: Experimental Evidence from Several Countries." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0006851. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6851-3.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Paul Christian* , Erin Kelley , Marcus Holmlund , Patrick Premand , Iva Trako , Gregory Lane , Jonas Heirman , Hanna Paulose , Chloe Fernandez , Eric Jospe , Dahyeon Jeong

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0006851
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6851-3.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2020-11-30 – 2025-12-01
Countries
Private
JEL codes
O22: Project Analysis; O19: International Linkages to Development; Role of International Organizations; H41: Public Goods; Q54: Climate; Natural Disasters and Their Management; Global Warming
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/6851

Abstract

The concept of resilience has gained attention because it recognises the importance of addressing shorter-term humanitarian needs while simultaneously supporting communities to face future crises induced by climate change, conflict, and other factors. Many institutions, including the World Food Programme (WFP), have increasingly used the concept as a basis for their programming. WFP's integrated packages of interventions aim to improve food security and nutrition by smoothing food consumption in the short-term, while supporting livelihoods and addressing barriers to development (e.g., better climate information, access to markets, education, WASH, etc.) in the long-term. While all programme activities are potentially important for building resilience, livelihood activities are clearly connected to both immediate and future wellbeing. These activities include cash or in-kind transfers to the household and support for creating assets that could benefit the household or the community in the future. Therefore, livelihood activities have the potential to support households in improving and maintaining their wellbeing when facing future shocks and stressors.

This pre-analysis plan describes policy experiments to estimate the impacts of experimentally varying WFP's activities on resilience as measured by community and household wellbeing. This approach follows others in conceptualizing resilience through changes in wellbeing (Knippenberg et al, 2019, Phadera et al. 2019, Jones and Tanner, 2017; Barrett et al, 2020). We design and run these experiments in the context of livelihoods programs implemented by the World Food Programme (WFP) across 6 countries. Beyond testing the overall impact of livelihood activities on wellbeing, a key ambition of this paper is to investigate whether activities themselves can be timed to accommodate households’ vulnerability to seasonal fluctuations and shocks that are often connected to weather patterns and agricultural cycle. We identify two such mechanisms: adjusting the timing of cash transfers and labor requirements; and/or allowing for re-targeting participants over time to account for changes in vulnerability status.

Intervention

We implement a multi-country study of WFP's resilience program. These programs typically englobe a wide set of multi-sector activities, such as livelihood support, and nutrition, health as well as education components.

Experimental design

We design an RCT that measures the impact of the WFP resilience program on welfare dynamics. To this end, villages are randomly allocated to two treatment arms and a control group. In the first treatment arm (UCT), WFP provides unconditional cash transfers to households. In the second treatment arm (CCT), WFP provides their cash-for asset program to selected beneficiaries. We compare CCT to control to isolate the benefits of a livelihood program on welfare dynamics. We compare the UCT to the CCT to understand whether the positive returns from the asset outweigh the costs that come from having to invest additional labor. In doing so we are able to isolate the benefit of assets on their own.

Beyond testing the overall impact of resilience and livelihood activities on wellbeing, a key ambition of this paper is to investigate whether activities themselves can be timed to accommodate households’ vulnerability to seasonal fluctuations and shocks that are often connected to weather patterns and agricultural cycle. We identify two such mechanisms: adjusting the timing of cash transfers and labor requirements; and/or allowing for re-targeting participants over time to account for changes in vulnerability status.

Design details

Randomization method
Both private randomizations done in office by a computer and public lotteries
Randomization unit
Village level randomization, with possible clustered approach in some areas (groups of villages)
Clusters
Approximately 200 villages per country (1,200 villages total)
Observations
Approximately 20 to 30 households per village (18,000 to 24,000 households)
Arms
We plan to implement all treatment arms where ever possible, with the following estimate sample size per treatment arm: -UCT: 50 villages per country (300 villages total) -CCT coupled: 25 villages per country (150 villages total) -CCT decoupled: 25 villages per country (150 villages total) -Control: 100 villages per country (600 villages total)
Primary outcomes
Consumption and Food Security; Time-use; Assets; Income Generating Activities; Shocks and Coping Mechanisms; Financial Outcomes; Migration; Psycho-social Well Being; Women's Empowerment; Social Capital, Safety-nets; Reservation Wages.
Sponsors
Name: BMZ Location: Germany Url: https://www.bmz.de/en/
Partners
Name: World Food Programme (WFP) Url: https://www.wfp.org/overview

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords