Experimenter Demand Effect in the Lab
How to cite
Mustafi, Priyoma; Wilson, Alistair; Vesterlund, Lise. 2020. "Experimenter Demand Effect in the Lab." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0006847. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6847-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We use four canonical behavioral predictions and test their sensitivity experimenter demand effects, using standard student subject pool of an experimental lab . Specifically we look at probability weighting, present bias, endowment effect and charitable giving and examine if demand effects can reverse the standard comparative static found in the literature.
Intervention
Using four standard results from the experimental economics literature, we test their sensitivity to experimenter demand effects. Following de Quidt et. al 2018, we test if and how demand effects affects the standard predictions of probability weighting , hyperbolic discounting , endowment effect and charitable giving in a dictator game. Specifically, we ask if using positive and negative experimenter demand effects appropriately can reverse the standard predictions observed in the literature.
Experimental design
We use a within-subject design in an individual decision-making study. Each participant is asked to make eight decisions, for each they begin with a $10 endowment. They are told they would be paid for only one of them.
For probability weighting, the participants are endowed with $10 to purchase a lottery ticket once for a 10% lottery of winning $10 and another for a 90% lottery of winning $10, while a random price for the lottery is determined between $0.01 and $10. The participant is asked to report their highest willingness to pay (WTP) for each of the lotteries. Using BDM, if the lottery price is greater than WTP, the participant do not buy the lottery and earn the $10.00.
If the lottery price is less than or equal to WTP, the participant buy the lottery and earn $10.00 minus the lottery price, plus the outcome of the lottery.
For endowment effect (in addition to WTP elicitation mentioned above), the participants are also asked to report their lowest WTA for both types of lotteries, and additionally they also receive $10 endowment for these decisions with a lottery price determined randomly. If the lottery price is less than the reported WTA, the participant does not sell the lottery and earn $10.00 plus the outcome of the lottery. If the lottery price is greater than or equal to their WTA, they sell the lottery and earn $10.00 plus the lottery price.
For hyperbolic discounting, the participants are asked to make two decisions, each asking them to decide how they would like to divide an endowment of $10, between a sooner and later payment, with the later payment. For one decision, individuals are asked to choose between today and a week from today, while in the other they are asked to choose between tomorrow and a week from tomorrow. For both the decisions, the participant earns an additional 20% interest on the amount they decide to receive later.
For charitable giving, we use a dictator game with the respondent framed as a charity. The participants are asked to decide how much of a $10 endowment, they would like to donate to the charity. For one decision, the charity receives the amount they donate while in another the donations are matched, i.e. the charity receives twice the amount of donation.
We have three treatments, in which we vary the kind of experimenter demand, following de Quidt et. al (2018). In a positive (negative) treatment, participants are urged to choose higher (lower) numbers, while in the control treatment nothing additional is mentioned.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.