Do Municipal Climate Protection Activities Interfere with Individual Engagement

How to cite

Bartels, Lara; Kesternich, Martin. 2020. "Do Municipal Climate Protection Activities Interfere with Individual Engagement." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0006807. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6807-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Lara Bartels* , Martin Kesternich

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0006807
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6807-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2020-10-19 – 2020-12-02
Countries
Private
JEL codes
Q51, Q54, C93, H41
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/6807

Abstract

The Paris Agreement aims at limiting the global average temperature increase to well below 2°C above preindustrial levels. A key component of the agreement are “nationally determined contributions” (NDC). For this, non-state actors such as civil society groups, economic actors, and subnational and local actors (e.g. Municipalities) play a decisive role. They can either directly reduce greenhouse gas emissions by additional voluntary activities, or indirectly by influencing the climate protection activities of individual actors. However, a successful integration of non-state actors must happen within the larger framework of the global climate regime. Literature (Johnson, Schroeder, and Toly 2015; Ostrom 2010; Romero-Lankao and Hardoy 201; Janicke and Quitzow, 2017) has already stressed the importance of a “polycentric” or multi‐level climate governance as an enabler for a transformation climate governance. As the role of non-state actors within reaching the climate goals has received little attention within research, our research focuses on the lowest rungs of the multi‐level climate governance ladder and analyses feedback loops between local non-state actors, here municipalities, and individual climate protection activities. With a framed-field experiment we aim to analyze the relationship between individual commitment to climate protection and the commitment of other fellow citizens, and the interaction between individual commitment and municipal engagement. Special attention is paid on potential crowding in or crowding out effects.

Intervention

The aim of the experiment is to investigate the relationships between non-state and individual actors. More precisely, the interaction between individual climate protection contributions and municipal engagement will be investigated on two levels: i. the relationship between individual commitment to climate protection and the commitment of other fellow citizens, and ii. the interaction between individual commitment and municipal engagement. Special attention is paid on potential crowding in or crowding out effects.

Experimental design

The procedure of the experiment is as follows: Participants were invited to answer a survey thematically unrelated to the experiment on the topic of the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). The LimeSurvey software was used to implement the online questionnaire and to generate personalized token to access the survey. The links were distributed to the participants via e-mail and direct mail. In the invitation email, participants were informed about the general content of the survey (General Data Protection Regulation GDPR), their fixed payment of 15 € for complete participation, and that payments were disbursed using PayPal.
After completing the online survey, participants were, for the first time, confronted with the opportunity to donate their fixed payment earned in the survey (15€) to support additional tree planting within an existing tree planting project. Before being able to make a donation, participants of all treatments received the same information about the need to protect our climate, the Parisian climate goals, and the role of trees as carbon sinks.
Unknown to the potential donors, subjects were then randomly allocated to one out of the three treatments, which vary a given reference value. In the first treatment T1, the basic treatment, the donation decision is framed in a neutral manner without giving any reference values. The mean willingness to donate of T1 are then used as reference value for the second treatment T2. Thus, T2 provides a reference value on the mean climate protection activities of other fellow citizens. Similarly, a reference value for municipal climate protection commitment is provided in T3.
The first intervention – our baseline treatment –took place from 19th to 4th November 2020, there no reference values were introduced. Based on the baseline treatment, we identify the reference values based on the mean donation for our second treatment – the Citizen Treatment. The third treatment – the City Treatment – gives a reference value based on a city initiative. The second and third treatment are run in parallel from the 16th to 1st December.

Design details

Randomization method
Participants will on the one hand be randomly selected from an existing database for experimental studies using a computer based random number generator mechanism. On the other hand, new participants are recruited by randomly distributed direct mail. By recruiting new participants to the existing database, it is kept active and diverse for future interventions.
Randomization unit
Participants
Clusters
The treatments are not clustered.
Observations
In total, we plan to collect 450 donation observations.
Arms
Participants are randomly allocated to the treatments, with an equal weighting of the treatments. Each treatment is planned to have 150 observations.
Primary outcomes
As primary outcome measures, we analyze the willingness to contribute to a local forest carbon sink / sequestration project in form of a donation decision. We will investigate both extensive margin (i.e. share of donors) and intensive margin (i.e. amount of money donated) effects and investigate the impact of giving a reference values of fellow citizens, of the fellow municipality, and none.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords