The registered study is a randomized controlled trial (RCT) implemented to assess the impact of a participatory agricultural extension program that aims to promote sustainable farming in rural China. We conduct this RCT in 135 villages, which are mainly grain farming villages in the North China Plain. Using detailed panel data, we explore if the program improves rural smallholders’ agricultural and environmental outcomes.
Intervention
We conduct a randomized controlled experiment with a total of 135 villages in the rural North China Plain. We implemented two types of extension programs as the main intervention arms. Intervention one is the participatory extension services, which integrates farmer field schools, field demonstrations, and case-to-case counseling to promote sustainable agricultural production among rural smallholders. This intervention is a modification of the China Agricultural University's science-and-technology-backyard [STB] design. The STB extension service is taking an active participatory approach to re-develop the local farming technologies (or farming practices) with the consultation from local stakeholders, including local smallholders, machinery service providers, cooperatives, inputs providers at the village. The re-developed farming technology is named by local extensionists as “double-high” technologies, which stands for high yield and high nutrient use efficiency. The technology redevelopment mainly derives from three primary concerns: (a) Local physical context adjustment, which enables extension services are locally relevant; (b) Local social context adjustment, which enables the recommended improved farming practices and technologies are socioeconomically feasible; (c) A local farmer-oriented technology dissemination approach, in which farmer field school, field demonstration, and case-to-case counseling are main activities implemented during the intervention.
Besides the STB extension services, treatment two is an extension program through text message (an SMS intervention), in which the content of SMS is equivalent to the STB extension service; however, the information was disseminated through the SMS. Rural smallholders were invited to receive the recommended farming practices (or the double-high technologies) through timely text messages.
Experimental design
The experiment is a factorial experimental design with two proposed interventions, thus we will have four treatment arms. Group 1 will only receive treatment 1 (the STB extension service program); Group 2 will receive only SMS treatment, and Group 3 will receive both treatment 1 and treatment 2; and the Group 4 will be the pure control group. We randomly assigned all 135 villages into four equal sized groups. There are 34 villages received only the STB extension services during 2018-2019; and 34 villages received the SMS treatment during the same period; and 34 villages received both the STB extension services and the SMS messages, and the remaining 33 villages receive no any treatment.
Design details
Randomization method
We used stata command “randomize” randomly assigned villages within each block (county) into four equal sized groups.
Randomization unit
It is a village-level clustered randomized controlled experiment. Village in rural China's context is the basic unit of a community. In Hebei province, the rural village on average containes about 100 to 500 households per village.
Clusters
In total, we have 135 clusters (rural villages) to participate in our experimental study.
Observations
Within each cluster, we randomly selected 16 rural households to participate in our survey. Field enumerators were asked to comply with the following criteria in selecting the interviewee within the household. First, the field survey can only be implemented with adults above 18 years old and not vulnerable groups (e.g. children below 16 years old, elderly, disabled, or mentally handicapped persons). Second, the interview should be mainly conducted with a household member who is in charge of farming decisions. If the household head is the main family member is doing (also making decisions of) farming, the household head should be interviewed as the first priority. If the household head was different from the main farming member within the family, then we interview the household member who is mainly in charge of the farming work.
Arms
All 135 clusters (villages) were randomly and evenly assigned to 4 different groups. There are 34 villages (524 surveyed rural households) were assigned to received treatment 1, 34 villages (535 rural households) were assigned to receive treatment 2, 34 villages (about 538 rural households) were assigned to receive treatment 1 and treatment 2, and last, there were 33 villages (about 522 rural households) assigned as the pure control group, and these 33 villages did not receive any treatment.
Primary outcomes
The outcomes of our study, following the research hypotheses, can be divided into three levels: (a) the intermediate outcomes, which are mainly the outcomes that used to explain smallholder’s final behaviors; (b) the behavioral outcomes, which are mainly about smallholder’s actual farming practices; and (c) smallholder’s agricultural production, environmental and socioeconomic outcomes. The structure of these outcomes is presented as shown in Figure 1 (in the attached project document).
Secondary outcomes
The secondary outcomes we are interested includes two levels outcomes:
(1) Intermediate outcomes that we have presented in the causal chain analysis and the research hypothesis test. It incluldes smallholder's knowledge of sustainable farming, their awareness of consequences of unsustainable farming practices, smallholder's perceptive elasticity of chemcial inputs and their preceived behavioral control and their behavioral attitude.
(2) Smallholder's farming behavvioral changes. We focus on types of farming behaviors: First, smallholder's farming practices that enhance their agricultural production (productivity enhancement behaviors). The field practices that could enhance smallholder’s agricultural production can be summarized in six specific segments, including land preparation, seeding, fertilization, irrigation, plant protection and harvest. Second, we focus on smallholder's framing practices to improve their environmental sustainability. The field practices that could enhance smallholder’s environmental sustainability mainly focuses on the chemical inputs—chemical fertilizer use, and the pesticide and herbicide use.
Sponsors
Name: The Science and Technology Backyard
Location: Hebei
Url: http://chinastb.com/
Name: China Agricultural University
Location: Beijing
Url: http://zihuan1.cau.edu.cn/
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.