Gender inequality in contributions to Wikipedia
How to cite
Li, Linfeng; Chen, Yan; Miller, David; Niederle, Muriel. 2020. "Gender inequality in contributions to Wikipedia." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0006753. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6753-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We explore why women do not contribute to Wikipedia as much as men do. Researchers and the Wikimedia Foundation estimate that Wikipedia editors are predominantly men. This gender gap leads to the biased coverage of women as well as topics important to women, such as women's health. In an intermediate microeconomics class at a large public university in the United States, we will randomly assign Wikipedia articles on economists' biographies or economic concepts to students who can earn bonus points by completing this assignment. Students will also complete a set of games as measurements of personal traits and a survey experiment to explore why we might observe a gender gap in contributions to economic concepts but not in biographies.
Intervention
We explore why women do not contribute to Wikipedia as much as men do. Researchers and the Wikimedia Foundation estimate that Wikipedia editors are predominantly men. This gender gap leads to the biased coverage of women as well as topics important to women, such as women's health. In an intermediate microeconomics class at a large public university in the United States, we will randomly assign Wikipedia articles on economists' biographies or economic concepts to students who can earn bonus points by completing this assignment. Students will also complete a set of games as measurements of personal traits and a survey experiment to explore why we might observe a gender gap in contributions to economic concepts but not in biographies.
Experimental design
In Fall 2020 semester, we plan to recruit participants from an Intermediate Microeconomics course, Econ 401, which has more than 400 registered students. Econ 401 is one of the two core economic theory courses at the university and is a prerequisite for a large number of upper-level electives in the Economics Department. Students enrolled in Econ 401 are usually in their sophomore or junior year, with an intention to declare a major in Economics. To incentivize student participation, the instructor introduced the experiment as a series of bonus point activities, with a cumulative weight of 1% of the total course grade.
The first bonus point activity is introduced as a battery of games and survey as "Pre-treatment measurements", where we measure the risk preference, level-k thinking, conditional and unconditional trust, and complex problem-solving skills (Knapsack game, a discrete optimization problem).
After students complete the online games and surveys, we will randomly assign them to two experimental conditions, stratified by gender and their Econ 401 exam scores. Students are randomized into receiving two Wikipedia articles on either (1) economists' biographies or (2) economics concepts which the instructor has covered in Econ 401. For each Wikipedia article, we provide an authoritative source that the student can use as a reference. Each student is assigned a unique set of Wikipedia articles.
After the main editing activities, we will circulate a debriefing survey immediately after. For each subject, we measure the absolute and relative confidence based on two incentivized survey questions. For each of the assigned Wikipedia pages, we ask students to evaluate the amount of expertise required to edit the pages and rate the overall qualification (in terms of academic standing) as needed to edit the assigned pages.
For more details, please refer to Section 2 in the Supporting Document.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.