Does information on regional income differentials change migration intentions? A survey experiment in multiple African countries
How to cite
Ebert, Cara; Frohnweiler, Sarah; Beber, Bernd. 2020. "Does information on regional income differentials change migration intentions? A survey experiment in multiple African countries." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0006733. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6733-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We propose to study whether information on regional wage differentials affects internal migration intentions and choices in two African countries. The information treatment is embedded in surveys of participants in employment and income promoting programs in Ghana and Uganda. We randomly assign participants to an information treatment group and a no-intervention control group. Interviews are conducted in person in Ghana and by phone in Uganda. In Ghana, treatment group participants are shown a map of the country’s ten regions, which depicts the monthly per capita income in each region. In Uganda, treatment group participants are told how much the monthly median wage is in each region and how many times more or less that is in comparison to the median monthly wage in their region of residence. Our two primary outcomes are the extent to which participants would like to move to another domestic region and their internal migration destination choices.
Intervention
The intervention consists of an information treatment about regional income or wage differentials in Ghana and Uganda, respectively. The information treatment is embedded in surveys of potential participants in employment and income promoting programs in each country. The survey is conducted face-to-face in Ghana and by phone in Uganda, and implementation of the information treatment depends on the survey mode.
In Ghana, a random subset of participants is presented with a map, which outlines the ten regions of Ghana and depicts the monthly per capita income in each region. To make the income information easily comprehensible, monthly per capita income is illustrated via stacks of coins, with one coin for each 100 GHS. The map is shown by a facilitator who explains the map and the information it contains to the participant. The information on average monthly per capita incomes is based on the seventh round of the Ghana Living Standards Survey (GLSS 7) from 2016/2017 conducted by the Ghana Statistical Service.
In Uganda, a random subset of participants is presented with information on monthly median wage differentials over the telephone. The information provided comprises the monthly median wage in each of Uganda’s four regions plus the capital city Kampala and how many times more or less that wage is relative to the participant’s region of residence. The information on the monthly median wage by region was gathered from the Uganda National Household Survey 2016/2017 Report of the Uganda Bureau of Statistics.
Experimental design
Experimental arms:
The information treatment is randomly assigned to survey respondents at the individual level. The experiment comprises two experimental arms: (i) one information treatment arm and (ii) one no-intervention control arm. Each participant has a 50% chance to be assigned to the treatment and control group, respectively.
Sampling strategy:
The information treatment is embedded in two distinct surveys, (a) a baseline survey of a randomized controlled trial on the effectiveness of a program for the Professionalization of Artisans (ProfArts) in Ghana and (b) an endline survey of an impact evaluation of a skills training and internship placement program in Uganda.
In Ghana, face-to-face interviews are conducted with up to 20,000 craftsmen in the construction sector in all ten regions of Ghana. Craftsmen are mobilized through a nationwide outreach campaign including flyers, posters, radio jingles and social media and all interested craftsmen can register for program participation. In total, up to 20,000 artisans will be mobilized and registered across Ghana, out of which a random subset of 10,000 people are selected for ProfArts benefits. Additionally, a further set of subjects may be recruited through other programs under the same funding umbrella.
In Uganda, phone interviews will be conducted with approximately 1,400 people who registered their interest in participating in a skills training and internship placement program supported by the German Corporation for International Cooperation (GIZ). The program was advertised over social media and the radio, among other channels. The skills training program was implemented at two training sites in Packwach (Northern region) and Kampala whereas internship placements did not have these regional restrictions.
Implementation procedure:
In both countries respondents are asked the same set of questions in the module for this study. First, we collect information about participants’ migration intentions within their country of residence, including the extent to which they would like to move and their top two destination choices. Second, participants are asked to indicate their perceptions on the average monthly per capita income (Ghana) or median monthly wage (Uganda) in each region before the coronavirus pandemic. Third, a random subset of participants receives the information treatment. Fourth, respondents are asked once again about their migration intentions and preferred destinations.
In both countries the surveys start in mid-November 2020. In Uganda, the survey is scheduled to be completed by the end of 2020 and in Ghana by mid-2021.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.