Learning Beyond School: Another Chance for Out of School Adolescent Girls in Pakistan
How to cite
Jamal, Khushbakht Fatima; Lucas, Adrienne; Beg, Sabrin; Fitzpatrick, Anne; Sheikh, Hibah. 2021. "Learning Beyond School: Another Chance for Out of School Adolescent Girls in Pakistan." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0006730. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6730-1.3000000000000003
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Despite substantial increase in primary school enrollment in Pakistan, 59% of girls do not complete primary school. Scant research exists on improving learning and later life outcomes for out of school female adolescents. We have designed a randomized controlled trial that will test the effect of a remedial learning and functional literacy program aimed at females aged 9 to 19 in southern Punjab (Pakistan) who have either never attended school or have dropped out. We will test the program’s effects on female learning, future enrollment, and educational aspirations, female empowerment, and the broader values and perceptions of female roles of both participants and their household and village members. The research will answer questions crucial to the welfare of some of the most marginalized and disadvantaged members of low income countries. Moreover, improving the position of young females can have strong spillovers through their roles as siblings and mothers.
Intervention
The learning program is being conducted by Idara Taleem-o-Agahi (ITA), a renowned champion of education in Pakistan, and supported by Department for International Development (DFID). It focuses on accelerated learning and capacity building of out of school and highly marginalized adolescent girls through education, livelihoods and life skills. ITA has developed a unique six-month curriculum designed for girls who have dropped out from either primary or middle school and a three-month core literacy program for girls who have never been to school.
The six-month program, called the short-term primary (STP) and short-term middle (STM), will prepare the dropout girls to undertake their board examinations for grade 5 and grade 8, respectively. The three-month Chalo-Parho-Barho (CPB) program is for the adolescent girls who have never been to school and aims to provide basic literacy and numeracy skills, aligned with grade 2 curriculum.
Experimental design
We will measure impact of Idara Taleem-o-Agahi (ITA)’s remedial learning programs on female education and empowerment through a village-clustered randomized evaluation. The programs consist of a 6-month program (for girls with some schooling) and a 3-month program (for girls with no previous schooling). In the treatment villages, all households with eligible girls will be offered the opportunity to enroll their adolescent girls in either the six-month or the three-month functional literacy program, depending upon the girl's prior schooling record. We will maintain status quo in the control villages.
Our study will take place in Bahawalpur and Muzaffargarh districts in Punjab. In both districts, we take the universe of villages from administrative sources, and restrict to those villages that have a minimum number of households, and those that have never before received the program. Among villages that meet these eligibility criteria, we have done pair-wise matching by district and village size; within each pair, one village is randomly assigned to either receive ITA’s programs or not.
ITA is only able to implement their program if villages meet certain criteria, namely sufficient community support and interest, as well as a location to hold the lessons. We refer to this phase as the “mobilization” phase. Therefore, we randomly ordered all pairs so as to create a “priority” list in the event a treatment village failed mobilization,a new treatment village could take its place and the corresponding pair could be added to the sample. This priority ordering was stratified by geographic area.
In Muzaffargarh, we conducted a baseline survey in 102 villages, consisting of 51 pairs split between treatment and control villages. In each village, we conducted a listing exercise and then surveyed approximately 25 households with an eligible (never enrolled or dropout) adolescent female, giving us a sample of roughly 2,500 households. Following our baseline survey, ITA entered treatment villages and conducted a mobilization exercise. After the mobilization phase, only 26 of the 51 treatment villages that we conducted baseline in were able to have the program launched. We used the priority list and then found replacement treatment villages so as to arrive at the total amount of 35 program villages. Therefore, we only have a baseline survey in 26 out of 35 treatment villages, or 25 girls per village*26 villages*2(corresponding control village) = 1,300 adolescents with a baseline survey. We plan to conduct an endline survey of all of these same adolescents at the conclusion of the program. Pending budget, we may also conduct endline visits in both treatment and control villages at which we lack a baseline.
In Bahawalpur we were not able to begin data collection prior to the implementation of the program and thus do not have a true baseline survey for this district. In Bahawalpur treatment villages, we implemented a household-level randomization of the 3 month program, conducting a “midline” survey after the completion of one wave of the program and before the beginning of the second wave of the program (cohorts 1 and 2, respectively). We obtained from the implementing partner the names of all girls who were eligible for the programs and whose households expressed interest during a community mobilization activity; there were 55 eligible girls from each village on average in this data. Then, we randomized households into two cohorts (Cohort 1 or Cohort 2). Randomization was done at the household-level so that all girls of the same household could participate at the same time. We plan to survey approximately 55 girls after Cohort 1 concludes and prior to the start of Cohort 2 giving us a tentative sample of 55*34 = 1,870 for the midline data collection. We will also survey the ITA teacher in each treatment village to collect data on attendance. Pending budget, we will conduct a listing exercise and an endline in the 70 districts of Bahawalpur (half treatment and half control).
Therefore, across the two districts we will ideally collect endline data on 30 households with an eligible adolescent female in the 70 pairs of villages, half treatment and half control. This brings the total sample size for the endline to 140*30 = 4200 households. This will be the target sample size for the endline.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.