Beliefs on the speed of Integration
How to cite
Schmidt, Stefan; Sutter, Matthias; Schwerter, Frederik. 2020. "Beliefs on the speed of Integration." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0006711. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6711-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This project studies the role of beliefs regarding immigrants' speed of integration for immigration preferences. The recent European migrant crisis and US President Trump’s immigration rhetoric and, in particular, his plan’s on a potential border wall are prominent manifestations of what many scholars, pundits, and lay persons understand to be one of the fundamental challenges of the 21st century: how can Western democracies deal with high levels of immigration? We approach this topic by investigating the determinants of immigration preferences. We conduct a representative survey in Germany and relate immigration preferences to individuals’ beliefs regarding immigrants’ speed of integration pertaining to Germany’s culture and economy. We predict that subjects with more benevolent immigration preferences believe immigrants to integrate quickly, while unfavorable immigration preferences are associated with beliefs of slower integration speed. In further analyses, we seek to investigate whether: (i) certain dimensions of integration (pertaining to Germany’s culture or economy) are more relevant for this relationship between the speed of integration and immigration preferences; (ii) we can uncover interesting between-individual heterogeneity in relation to socioeconomic status and exposure to immigration; (iii) the provision of hard information and anecdotal evidence on the speed of integration causally affects immigration preferences.
Experimental design
We designed a novel method to measure how quickly individuals believe that immigrants integrate into the German society. We take existing data on the speed of integration of immigrants in Germany pertaining to several cultural and economic issues and group responses according to:
1.) Immigrants that migrated 5 or less years ago
2.) Immigrants that migrated 5-15 years ago
3.) Immigrants that migrated 15-25 years ago
4.) Immigrants that migrated 25+ years ago
Next we ask a representative sample in Germany to predict average responses for each group and infer respondents' expected speed of integration by comparing beliefs across groups. In addition we elicit immigration preferences and several background demographics. Then we relate our new measure of expected speed of integration with actual immigration preferences.
We employ three treatment arms that differ on the information provided after the elicitation of beliefs on speed of integration and before the eliciation of immigration preferences. "Treatment_Control" receives no information. "Treatment_Info" receives a statistic on the actual speed of integration. Data for this statistic is taken from (Harder, Figueroa, et al, (2018)). "Treatment_Anecdotal" also receives the statistic but additionally an anecdotal story of an immigrant and her integration story. This story is build upon the mentioned statistic and contains equivalent information.
Our prediction is that subjects with more benevolent immigration preferences believe immigrants to integrate quickly, while unfavorable immigration preferences are associated with beliefs of slower integration speed. In further analyses, we seek to investigate whether: (i) certain dimensions of integration (pertaining to Germany’s culture or economy) are more relevant for this relationship between the speed of integration and immigration preferences; (ii) we can uncover interesting between-individual heterogeneity in relation to socioeconomic status and exposure to immigration; (iii) the provision of hard information and anecdotal evidence on the speed of integration causally affects immigration preferences.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.