We investigate the role of memory in how individuals form probabilistic beliefs. In particular, we present subjects with a series of images with multiple features (content vs color). We measure how beliefs about the distribution of these features vary depending on both normatively relevant and normatively irrelevant features of the distribution of images. We plan to connect these results to a model of memory to explain why sometimes people hold too extreme of beliefs, while at other times beliefs appear to be too conservative.
Experimental design
We present subjects with a series of images with multiple features (content vs color). We measure how beliefs about the distribution of these features vary depending on both normatively relevant and normatively irrelevant features of the dsitribution.
Design details
Randomization method
We use qualtrics' randomization function.
Randomization unit
Treatment is randomized at the individual level. The order of images, conditional on treatment, is randomized as well.
Clusters
1200 individuals
[Second wave of experiments]: Also 1200 individuals
Observations
1200 individuals
Arms
150 respondents per treatment group.
[Second wave of experiments]: 240 respondents per treatment group
Primary outcomes
Our primary outcome variable is respondents' beliefs about the probability that a randomly drawn image has a certain content (word vs number) conditional on receiving information (or not) about whether the image is a certain color (blue vs orange).
[Added after first set of experiments]: In the second part of the experiments, our primary outcome variable is respondent's beliefs about the probability that a randomly drawn word belongs to a certain category.
Secondary outcomes
We have several secondary outcomes. We measure how confident subjects are (on a likert scale) that their probabilistic answers are correct. We also have two separate memory tasks. First, respondents are given a series of four words, and are ask "Was X (in C) among the images you were shown?" where C is a color and the word X is displayed in that color font. The correct answer to this question is always "no", and we are measuring how frequently respondents incorrectly believe that they saw the word. Our second memory task simply asks them to list all the orange words they remember having been shown.
[Added after first set of experiments]: In the second part of the experiments, we also have certainty measurements, as well as recall measurements for each category.
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.