Can smallholder extension transform African agriculture?

How to cite

Duru, Maya; Siegal, Kimberly; Deutschmann, Joshua; Tjernstrom, Emilia. 2021. "Can smallholder extension transform African agriculture?." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0006675. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6675-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Maya Duru* , Kimberly Siegal , Joshua Deutschmann , Emilia Tjernstrom

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0006675
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6675-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2016-12-01 – 2018-05-01
Countries
Kenya ()
JEL codes
O12, O13, Q12
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/6675

Abstract

Agricultural productivity in Sub-Saharan Africa lags behind all other regions of the world. Decades of investment in agricultural research and extension have yielded more evidence on what fails than on what works—especially for the small-scale producers who dominate the sector. We study a program that targets multiple constraints to productivity at once, similar to anti-poverty “graduation” interventions. Analyzing a randomized controlled trial in western Kenya, we find that participation causes statistically and economically significant gains in output, yields, and profits. In our preferred specification, the program increases maize production by 26% and profits by 16%. The program increases yields uniformly across the sample, while treatment effects on total output and profit impacts are slightly attenuated at the top end of the distribution.

Intervention

Farmers in the the treatment group received One Acre Fund's “market bundle” which provides farmer groups with group-liability loans for improved seeds and fertilizer, regular training on modern agricultural techniques, crop and funeral insurance, and market facilitation support to help farmers obtain higher prices for their output.

Experimental design

Recruitment, enrollment, and program implementation for this experiment took place in the Teso region of Kenya, following 1AF's standard
protocol. Farmers who satisfied the basic program criteria paid a participation deposit of approximately $5 USD. Once participants had self-selected into groups of 8-12 farmers, the randomization was conducted at the level of clusters, which consisted of 2-4 of these joint-liability farmer groups.

Although 1AF had never offered its program to the sampled villages, some farmers had managed to access it anyway, by "commuting" to
neighboring villages to participate. As pre-exposed farmers may introduce bias into our results we report our main results both for the full sample and for the "primary sample," which refers to the sample of farmers who had never participated in 1AF programming.

Design details

Randomization method
A public lottery assigned groups of farmers into treatment clusters
Randomization unit
cluster, where each cluster is made up of 2-4 farmer groups
Clusters
120 clusters, each cluster is made up of 2-4 farmer groups
Observations
2545 farmers
Arms
60 clusters in treatment and 60 clusters in control
Primary outcomes
The primary outcomes are program maize yields, total maize output, and profits. Program maize yields are treated farmers' per-acre yield on their enrolled plot. Total maize output is a weighted average of per-acre yields on the enrolled vs. non-enrolled plot (with weights proportional to the amount of land in each category). To obtain "crop cut" yields, enumerators collected and physically weighed fresh and dry harvests from two randomly placed 40-square-meter boxes. Cultivated land sizes were measured by GPS readings, with enumerators walking the boundaries of each plot three times. We calculate profi t as the value of output less farmers' costs. Revenues are the product of total output and average market prices from nearby vendors. For control farmers, input costs are elicited via self-reports. For treatment farmers, we know the input costs on the enrolled land (since these are administered by the program); we elicit other input costs with self-reports.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords