Projection bias in an aversive environment
How to cite
Zhang, Sili. 2020. "Projection bias in an aversive environment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0006659. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6659-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This project aims to demonstrate the existence of projection bias (Loewenstein et al.,2003), the behavioral tendency to project current preferences into the future, in an aversive environment. The main objective is to collect the first stage result in order to calculate the effect size needed for further studies.
Intervention
Bad state treatment: participants will have a loud background sound played constantly in the headset while making evaluation choices.
Good state treatment: participants will not have the background sound played in the headset while making evaluation choices.
Experimental design
The experiment aims to detect state dependence as predicted by projection bias (Loewenstein et al.,2003). The state is varied by the presence of an aversive event, annoying noises. Specifically, participants will be required to complete a few transcription tasks (cover-up tasks) and sit through 20 minutes with an annoying background sound that will come and go for about half of the time in different time intervals (less than 80dB; around 5 seconds each). The main outcome variable of interest is participants' willingness-to-pay (WTP) to lower the volume from loud to moderate, which will be elicited using an incentive-compatible BDM procedure.
Depending on the treatment, the willingness-to-pay choices will be elicited in one of the two decision states, with the loud noises played constantly in the headset (in a bad state treatment) or without (in a good state treatment). Participants will have full experience of the sound with both full and reduced volume before making any decisions. Therefore, any treatment effect cannot be attributed to rational learning.
The remaining part of the experiment aims to collect a variety of measures in order to pin down mechanisms. For instance, it includes projection bias measured by a real effort task allocation in the spirit of Augenblick and Rabin (2019). It also includes two self-reported measures based on the idea of shopping on an empty stomach and buyer's remorse, each of which reflects the nature of earlier studies on projection bias (e.g. Read and van Leeuwen, 1998; Colin et al., 2007; Busse et al., 2014). For sake of power, I will only conduct heterogeneity analysis if I obtain the first stage result with enough significance.
General noise sensitivity will also be included as a control variable. One concern in the current design is that people may have very subjective perceptions of aversiveness and this within-subject heterogeneity may dominate the effect induced by the between-subject treatment. If a plain comparison of means across treatment groups did not work as worried, I will have to separately analyze subgroups with different levels of noise sensitivity or rely on a regression framework with controls.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.