Training Effective Altruism: Experimental Evidence from Pakistan
How to cite
Chen, Daniel; Naseer, Shaheen; Mehmood, Sultan. 2020. "Training Effective Altruism: Experimental Evidence from Pakistan." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0006655. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6655-2.4
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Empathy is said to be the antidote to in-group bias. In this study we evaluate the causal effects of empathy training on elite civil servants in collaboration with the civil service administration and assess its impact on social preferences, bureaucratic performance, and thought leadership. Recent research suggests that emphasizing malleability of empathy as being key to behavioral change. In a factorial design, we also assess the impacts of emotional intelligence training, the impact of reading material whose content application is assessed via social emotional learning exercises. We also randomize econometrics book (mastering metrics) across the civil servants subject to their selection of the metrics book, where book on empathy serves as the other serves as a condition.
Update 13 March 2023. We are now also looking to evaluate the impact of empathy training (Utilitarian vs Malleavility vs Joint vs Control) using data from performance audits of civil servants. There are 12 government departments on which they can choose to recommend a budgetary allocation. We will evaluate the impact of our training on these 12 policy decisions in year 1 and year 2 post-treatment.
Intervention
In this study, we aim to test whether training in empathy affects civil service quality, measured in terms of social preferences in experimental games, performance on the job, and thought leadership footprint.
Experimental design
Lectures are delivered over zoom and randomized at the individual level. Empathy malleable vs. empathy utilitarian vs. both vs. control in online lectures. Class-wide lectures will also be randomized, focusing on emotional intelligence vs. macro-economics lectures.
Update March 13, 2023: We now also are collecting data on universe of spending decisions by the civil servants. Specificially, the study experimentally evaluates three methods of cultivating prosocial behaviour (i) Utilitarian Value of Empathy (ii) Malleability of Empathy (iii) Joint Utilitarian and Malleability Treatment (iv) Placebo treatment.
We outline two main categories of policies that are most likely to be impacted by altruism training. For instance, we expect social policies, i.e. spending on health and education departments, to be positively impacted and self-oriented policies, i.e. personal security and office budget, to be negatively affected (as they potentially crowd-out government funds). Our main hypothesis, therefore, is that spending on social policies will increase and spending on selfish policies will decrease, while the other 8 policies will be unaffected. For more details, see the pre-analysis plan.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.